Major setback for California’s restrictive recyclability labeling regime
On July 14, 2026, the US District Court for the Southern District of California issued a preliminary injunction prohibiting California Attorney General Rob Bonta from enforcing Senate Bill 343, California’s highly consequential “Truth in Recycling” law. California League of Food Producers, et al. v. Bonta, No. 3:26-cv-01675, 2026 WL 2055589 (S.D. Cal., July 14, 2026). The court concluded that the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on their constitutional vagueness claims and First Amendment challenge, ordering the halt of enforcement pending further proceedings.
Background: What SB 343 would have required
SB 343 substantially narrowed when manufacturers could label products or packaging as “recyclable” in California. The statute generally treated the use of the chasing arrows symbol, recyclability statements or other directions to recycle as deceptive unless strict statutory criteria were satisfied. Among other requirements, packaging had to meet California’s so-called “60/60” recyclability standard and several additional criteria related to actual recycling outcomes and package design.
The law was scheduled to become operative on October 4, 2026, following publication of CalRecycle’s material characterization study.
The court’s ruling
The court granted a preliminary injunction barring enforcement of SB 343 in its entirety pending resolution of the litigation. The decision rests on two independent grounds:
The court found key provisions unconstitutionally vague
The court held that plaintiffs were likely to succeed in showing that several critical provisions fail to provide adequate notice of prohibited conduct. The court identified four problematic provisions:
- The requirement that a material “routinely becomes feedstock” used to make new products or packaging.
- The requirement that materials are sent to reclaiming facilities “consistent with the requirements of the Basel Convention.”
- The incorporation of the Association of Plastic Recyclers (APR) Design® Guide.
- The requirement that products are designed to “ensure recyclability” and not contain features that “prevent recyclability.”
The court emphasized that manufacturers cannot reliably determine compliance with standards that depend on downstream market conditions, evolving industry guidance, recycling facility practices and information not readily available to product manufacturers.
The court found a likely First Amendment violation
The court also held that plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their commercial speech challenge under the Supreme Court’s Central Hudson framework.
The court concluded that recyclability claims are not inherently misleading and therefore remain protected commercial speech.
The court further found that California had not produced sufficient evidence demonstrating that SB 343 would either:
- Materially improve recycling rates
- Materially reduce consumer confusion
The court was particularly persuaded by evidence that companies may remove truthful recyclability information rather than redesign products, potentially reducing the amount of recycling information available to consumers.
The court also criticized SB 343’s broad restrictions on qualified recyclability statements, observing that the law could prohibit truthful disclosures such as “recyclable where facilities exist” or similar location-specific recycling guidance.
Because the court found less restrictive alternatives available, it concluded that SB 343 is likely more extensive than necessary to achieve California’s stated goals.
Practical implications for manufacturers, retailers and brand owners
Immediate effect: Enforcement is suspended
Unless the injunction is stayed or overturned on appeal, California cannot enforce SB 343 while the preliminary injunction remains in effect.
Companies that were modifying labels, artwork, marketing materials or California-specific packaging solely to comply with SB 343 may wish to reassess those plans in light of the injunction.
Existing recyclability claims may remain viable
Although the court's injunction suspends enforcement of SB 343, it does not eliminate the legal risks associated with recyclability claims. Companies that market products in California must continue to evaluate recyclability representations under the Federal Trade Commission's Green Guides, California's false advertising statutes and the growing body of consumer class-action litigation challenging environmental marketing claims.
The Green Guides already impose meaningful limitations on recyclability claims. Under the FTC's guidance, a product or package should not be marketed as recyclable unless it can be collected, separated or otherwise recovered through an established recycling program. Unqualified recyclable claims generally are appropriate only when recycling facilities are available to a "substantial majority" of consumers or communities where the item is sold, which the FTC defines as at least 60 percent. Where access falls below that threshold, marketers are expected to use clear and prominent qualifications.
The decision does not create a free pass for broad, unqualified recyclability claims. Rather, it pauses California-specific restrictions that go beyond the FTC framework. Environmental NGOs have already been active in bringing false advertising claims over recyclability. This result may motivate these groups to be even more active, and regardless of the injunction, they now have significant data on actual recyclability of materials as a result of the state’s preparations for SB 343. And class-action plaintiffs’ lawyers remain active in challenging recyclability claims under state deceptive trade practices laws, using similar arguments.
One of the most significant aspects of the court's opinion is its recognition of the value of qualified and contextual recyclability disclosures. The court repeatedly suggested that truthful statements regarding local recycling availability, component-specific recyclability and other nuanced recycling information may provide consumers with more useful information than an outright prohibition on recyclability messaging. This reasoning is largely consistent with the FTC's longstanding approach, which encourages marketers to qualify claims where recycling opportunities are limited rather than remain silent altogether.
The practical effect of the injunction may be less a return to broad, unqualified recyclability claims and more a renewed opportunity to utilize carefully substantiated, appropriately qualified recycling disclosures. Statements such as "recyclable where facilities exist," "check locally," component-specific recycling instructions, or similar contextual disclosures may now be easier to defend than they would have been under SB 343's more restrictive scheme, provided they are supported by adequate substantiation and presented in a manner that is not misleading.
Companies should also remain mindful that use of the chasing-arrows symbol presents separate compliance considerations. The FTC has taken the position that the symbol itself may convey messages regarding both recyclability and recycled content, depending on context. Manufacturers should continue to evaluate whether any accompanying qualifications or disclosures are necessary and maintain documentation supporting the implied claims conveyed by packaging symbols and environmental marketing statements.
California is likely to appeal
Because SB 343 is a cornerstone of California’s broader effort to address perceived greenwashing and improve recycling outcomes, an appeal to the Ninth Circuit is highly likely. The Ninth Circuit previously upheld earlier statutory restrictions on the use of terms such as “biodegradable” and “recyclable” in a first amendment challenge in Association of National Advertisers, Inc. v. Lungren, 44 F.3d 726 (9th Cir. 1994). The district court’s conclusion that the record in this case was distinguishable from the record in Lungren will be reviewed de novo.
Companies should not assume the litigation is over. The legal landscape could change significantly over the next 12–24 months.