A North Carolina case dealmakers should be following

A recent North Carolina Business Court decision highlights both the importance of careful drafting of post-closing service commitments in hospital transactions, as well as the continued sensitivity that can accompany the conversion of charitable assets when a non-profit hospital is sold to a for-profit hospital system.

The North Carolina Attorney General alleges that commitments concerning the continuation of certain medical services, such as oncology and emergency care, were not fulfilled, affecting patient access to care. At issue in the lawsuit are provisions in the asset purchase agreement governing those commitments. In Jackson v. HCA Mgmt. Servs., LP, the court held that key provisions were ambiguous or subject to competing interpretations, leaving the core questions for trial.

The decision serves as a reminder that service preservation covenants can become a focal point of post-closing scrutiny, particularly in transactions involving the conversion of charitable assets. Absent clear drafting and objective standards, parties may find themselves litigating years after closing over how post-closing core services commitments should be interpreted and compliance measured.

The court's ruling

The dispute arose from a hospital acquisition agreement that required the buyer, for 10 years after closing, to continue the provision of specified services, including emergency and trauma services and oncology services. The agreement did not define either the terms “discontinue” or “provision,” and the parties advanced competing interpretations of those terms with materially different implications for the buyer’s post-closing obligations in litigation brought years later by the Attorney General.

On cross-motions for summary judgment, the court concluded that the phrase “shall not discontinue” is ambiguous. The parties offered competing interpretations. The Attorney General argued that the covenant required the buyer to maintain services at a level generally comparable to what was available at closing, while the defendants argued that the covenant barred only the complete elimination of the covered services. Because the parties’ extrinsic evidence did not resolve that interpretive dispute, the court held that the meaning of “shall not discontinue” must be decided at trial by the finder of fact.

The court separately construed the term “provision” and rejected the argument that the covenant could be satisfied merely by maintaining the physical capacity associated with a service line. Instead, the court held that the covenant requires more than the maintenance of facilities or infrastructure alone and concluded that the agreement contemplates the actual availability of the covered services to patients. That holding did not establish breach, but it suggests that service-continuation covenants may be evaluated by reference to actual service availability rather than infrastructure alone.

The court also left for trial factual disputes regarding compliance with the service-continuation covenant as applied to certain covered services. At the same time, it granted summary judgment on one narrower claim involving surgical otolaryngology, or ENT, services, highlighting the importance of tying service-specific allegations to the text of the covenant and the evidentiary record.

Implications for hospital transactions

Although the decision arises from a specific transaction involving the conversion of charitable assets, issues relating to the preservation of access to care when such transactions occur are not new. The decision also has broader implications for hospital acquisitions that include service-line preservation commitments or other post-closing operational covenants. The case illustrates that terms such as “provide,” “maintain,” “continue” and “discontinue” should be defined with care when used in conjunction with promises to maintain a level of service or access at a defined point in time. Parties should also consider whether compliance will be measured by service availability, staffing levels, patient access, service volumes, operating hours, maintenance of regulatory designations or some combination of objective metrics. Absent such objective standards, the parties may later find themselves litigating not whether a service existed, but what level of functionality, accessibility or performance the covenant actually required.

The decision also shows the value of addressing whether temporary service disruptions, labor shortages, physician departures or similar operational pressures are meant to constitute noncompliance, as well as whether the parties want reporting, monitoring and cure mechanisms that can help resolve disputes in the agreement before they mature into litigation. Parties should also consider incorporating express force majeure, workforce shortage, recruitment failure and regulatory change carveouts where appropriate.

More broadly, the ruling is a reminder that post-closing hospital covenants should be drafted with sufficient specificity to reflect the parties’ intended operational obligations and community-facing commitments, particularly in transactions involving the conversion of charitable assets, because courts may otherwise be asked to resolve competing interpretations through fact-intensive litigation.

Conclusion

The court in this case did not decide whether the agreement was ultimately breached. The remaining factual questions will be resolved later in the litigation, making the case worth watching both for its implications regarding state attorney general oversight of the conversion of charitable assets and post-closing hospital commitments, as well as the guidance it may provide on drafting service-continuation obligations in future transactions. Absent specificity and inclusion of objective measurements of compliance, even a carefully negotiated covenant may become the subject of post-closing litigation over competing interpretations of the covenant and the obligations it imposes.

Special thanks to healthcare senior analyst Kathleen Rubinstein for assisting in the preparation of this article.

Contact