While employee appraisals are a routine part of HR performance management, employers in Singapore should be prepared to rigorously defend any decision taken to dismiss an employee for poor performance, as the recent case of JIW v JIX [2026] SGECT 7 (JIW) demonstrates.
In JIW v JIX [2026] SGECT 7, the Singapore Employment Claims Tribunals (ECT) clarified what is required of employers to dismiss an employee (on probation) for poor performance. The case dealt with an employee who had been terminated with contractual notice at the end of her probation period on grounds of poor performance – who then brought a statutory claim for wrongful dismissal under Section 14(2) of the Singapore Employment Act 1968 (EA), alleging that she was dismissed without “just cause or excuse”. On the facts, the ECT held that the employer had failed to prove that:
- the performance goals and standards the probationer would be required to meet had been sufficiently clear and communicated;
- the individual scores and ratings that produced the probationer’s aggregate performance grade were justified;
- the probationer’s performance / shortcomings were measured in a principled way; and
- dismissal was a justified and proportionate decision in the circumstances.
There was therefore no “just cause or excuse” for dismissing the probationer, and the employer was ordered to pay compensation of SGD 30,000 – up to the ECT’s maximum jurisdiction – for the probationer’s loss of income.
In this update, we highlight the key takeaways from the ECT’s decision in JIW.
Background to Section 14(2) of the EA
Section 14(2) of the EA allows an employee dismissed “without just cause or excuse” to bring a claim against the employer for reinstatement of employment or compensation up to the prescribed limit of SGD 20,000 (or SGD 30,000 in cases involving unions)1. This is a wide-ranging, independent, statutory cause of action, available to any employee who had been terminated by his employer, whether with or without contractual notice (or payment in lieu of notice). Employees who were given all their contractual entitlements (including notice or notice pay as required by the employment contract) can still bring a statutory claim for wrongful dismissal.
The employer bears the burden of proving the employee’s poor performance if a notice of termination (dismissing the employee with notice or payment in lieu of notice) is or purports to be given on that ground2. In this regard, it is crucial to note that, in the absence of misconduct or wilful breach, employers may not dismiss an employee summarily (i.e., without notice and without payment in lieu of notice) on the ground of poor performance, as doing so would be in breach of Sections 11(2) and 14(1) of the EA.
Brief facts in JIW
The claimant, who had 15 years of audit experience, was employed as a regional internal control audit manager, subject to a probation period of six months. The employer had a probation management process, which served as the foundation for its assessment of the claimant. Under the assessment framework, the claimant had to achieve: (i) an overall score of at least 80% for her agreed performance goals (the performance goals), and (ii) an average rating of at least 3 out of 5, across 10 functional competencies (the functional competencies). The claimant was told from the outset that those were the requirements to be satisfied to be confirmed for permanent employment.
However, at the end of her probation, the claimant was assessed to have failed both requirements – she attained an overall score of 71% on the 4 performance goals (falling below the required 80%), and an average competency rating of 2.4 out of 5 (falling below the required 3 out of 5), as 6 of the 10 competencies were given a below-average rating of 2 out of 5 (the 6 contested competencies). The claimant was informed that her performance had not met the standards required for confirmation and was terminated on two weeks’ written notice.
Before the ECT, the claimant did not challenge the probation management framework. Instead, she challenged the individual scores and ratings that produced her aggregate result – that is, whether the shortcomings the employer identified in respect of each goal and competency were proven, and whether they were assessed against standards that were sufficiently clear and communicated.
The ECT’s decision in JIW
The ECT confirmed that the burden was on the employer to establish its allegation of poor performance against the claimant3. To that end, the ECT undertook an unusually granular review of how the claimant’s performance was assessed and found that the employer had not proven that the claimant fell below its suitability standards in a manner that would constitute just cause or excuse for dismissal. Specifically, for the reasons outlined below, the employer failed to prove that the individual scores and ratings which produced the claimant’s aggregate result were themselves justified.4
The ECT examined the individual ratings and scores (including deductions) for all components where the claimant was marked down, as a higher score on any one component would have resulted in an overall passing grade.5
The ECT applied the following principles in evaluating the employer’s assessment:
- Employer must demonstrate that specific performance standards had been communicated with sufficient clarity: The overarching principle is that an employer who has not made its performance standards clear cannot then rely on an employee’s non-conformity with those standards as evidence of unsuitability.6
Although the ECT acknowledged that exhaustively articulating every standard may be unnecessary where it is self-evident (e.g., where it relates to failings so material that any reasonable employer would regard them as gross incompetence), the matters for which the claimant was penalised were largely peripheral and unrelated to what she would have been expected to know as an experienced audit professional. It was for the employer to inform the claimant of precisely the kind of expectations that an employee unfamiliar with a new organisation’s culture and practices would require guidance on – but it failed to do so.7 - Qualitative descriptors of standards were inadequate on their own: As the 6 contested competencies (namely, collaboration, driving force, business acumen, work standards, decision-making, and global perspective) were qualitative in nature and capable of a wide range of interpretations, they were by themselves insufficient to provide specific and documented foundation for the final ratings given.8
- Employer failed to follow its own probation management process that was designed to adequately inform the claimant at the outset and provide periodic feedback: Although the employer’s probation management process required both an initial meeting between the probationer and her supervisor to explain clearly what each functional competency meant and what a passing rating required, as well as ongoing periodic documented reviews to provide feedback on what is required to pass probation, the claimant’s supervisor did none of this.9
- The importance of a specific task to the achievement of a composite goal (covering a range of tasks) must be explained: A genuine failure to perform a task is insufficient if the significance of the task to the overall assessment was not clearly communicated. Therefore, even though the supervisor had provided adequate instructions on a particular assignment and the claimant was found to have failed to properly complete it10, such proven failure was insufficient to justify a significant 40% deduction on a composite goal as the claimant was not told the particular assignment would have such a significant impact on the scoring process.11
- Performance goals and weightages should not be unilaterally adjusted by the employer: Of the 5 performance goals established at the outset, the fifth goal which carried a weightage of 10% became redundant as the underlying task had been reassigned to another employee. However, the supervisor unilaterally (and without any discussion with the claimant) decided to transfer the 10% weightage from the fifth goal to the third goal, effectively doubling the significance of the third goal. This led the claimant – who had certain shortcomings in the tasks categorised under the third goal – to be heavily penalised when she had no reason to appreciate that those tasks were that important to the overall assessment.12
- Employer must demonstrate that there were specific shortcomings that had a substantive, material impact on the completion of a goal: Although the claimant was marked down by 25% on the first and second performance goals, the ECT was not persuaded that the deductions were justified by the shortcomings alleged. In particular, the claimant had substantively completed the task under the first goal by the deadline, and the supervisor’s comments were mere editorial distinctions that could have been resolved by a simple instruction to the claimant. The employer also produced no evidence that the purported delays were attributable to the claimant’s conduct rather than other factors beyond her control. To the extent there were deficiencies in the claimant’s performance in respect of a particular task, the ECT was of the view that those deficiencies did not have any material consequence on the completion of the goal.13
- Employer must justify the magnitude of a significant deduction on an individual goal: A deduction of a significant magnitude is only warranted if it reflected a genuine failure by the employee to meet a known standard. Crucially, at no point did the supervisor criticise the substantive quality of the claimant’s audit work, which was what the first performance goal required; instead, criticisms were confined largely to peripheral and administrative matters. If administrative compliance was to carry sufficient weight – to warrant a deduction with direct adverse implications for the claimant’s ability to pass probation – the supervisor should have made that clear to the claimant in terms specific enough for her to understand what was expected and calibrate her conduct accordingly.14
- Employer must produce documentary evidence: While the supervisor claimed to have informed the claimant of the scope of work required for a particular task that was assessed under the fourth performance goal, the employer did not adduce any form of corroborating evidence – whether in the form of email, meeting record, documented discussion, or sample work product allegedly provided to the claimant for reference.15 While the claimant also produced no documentary evidence, that was understandable given her lack of access to company records. More importantly, the employer bore the burden of proof – which it failed to discharge.16
- Justifications should be properly recorded: The employer’s probation evaluation form was left incomplete by the supervisor. In particular, the dedicated column for the supervisor to record her justification for each rating was left blank. While oral justifications were given at the hearing before the ECT, they did not withstand scrutiny.17
- High-level impressions are insufficient where there are no proven failures against a defined standard: The supervisor’s general impressions of the claimant (e.g., that the claimant had difficulties working with the team, might not be that passionate about certain tasks, and was inattentive or uninterested) were held to be insufficient to justify a below-average grade that placed the claimant’s continued employment at risk. The ECT held that it was not enough to point to general impressions of inadequacy – untethered to any defined standard and unsupported by any documented observation – without articulating the standard required to achieve a passing rating and demonstrating that the employee was measured against it.18
Ultimately, although the employer succeeded in proving certain shortcomings of the claimant19, the ECT was not persuaded that those proven shortcomings demonstrated that the claimant was more likely than not incompetent or unsuitable to be confirmed for regular employment, such that dismissal was a justified and proportionate decision by the employer in the circumstances.20
As to remedies, the claimant – who had been unable to find alternative employment – was entitled to compensation comprising: (i) loss of income, up to 3 months’ pay; and (ii) compensation for (non-pecuniary) harm caused by the wrongful dismissal, comprising a base amount of 2 months’ pay, subject to adjustment for any aggravating or mitigating factors.
As the claimant would have at the very least been employed for a further 3 months under an extended probation period if not for the wrongful dismissal, her loss of income was equivalent to 3 months’ pay at SGD 34,500. The ECT therefore awarded the sum of SGD 30,000, being the maximum prescribed claim limit in the matter. Given that the award of SGD 30,000 already exhausted the prescribed claim limit, no compensation for harm was awarded. The ECT however observed that had the claim ceiling permitted it, the claimant would have been awarded an additional 2 months’ salary, as the employer had brought the claimant’s employment to an end in a manner that was both sudden and unjustified, and it would be difficult to suppose that such a dismissal did not cause her considerable distress.21
Key takeaways
The decision in JIW has significant implications for employers in terms of performance management and HR record keeping. Although the ECT accepted that it “should not sit as a superior manager, ready to second-guess every such determination”22, the case of JIW demonstrates that the ECT could still delve into details and employers have to be ready to justify its performance assessments and substantiate them with clear documentation. In that regard, the ECT (in a separate reported case) stated that it would conduct a de novo (i.e., “from the beginning”) review to determine whether “just cause or excuse” existed.23
Ultimately, as the ECT recognised in JIW, “[w]here an employer can demonstrate that an employee fell below a reasonably calibrated suitability standard, that would, in principle, constitute just cause or excuse for dismissal in most cases.24” To demonstrate this, the employer will likely be required to have comprehensive records, showing (among other things):
- how the scoring methodology (including the assessment rubric and individual weightages) was disclosed and explained to the employee in advance;
- the instructions given to the employee for specific pieces of work that would be assessed;
- the employee’s actual shortcomings or failures;
- the employee’s explanations for the alleged shortcomings or failures;
- how those alleged shortcomings or failures had a material impact on the substance of what the employee was required to do;
- why the alleged shortcomings or failures warranted a significant deduction or penalty;
- any feedback provided to the employee or interim assessment conducted; and
- how the overall final grade, and the individual scores given to each component of the assessment, were justified and proportionate in the circumstances.
Employers should therefore review their existing HR policies and practices, bearing in mind the level of potential scrutiny and types of contemporaneous, written evidence required.
In all cases of dismissal, employers should carefully consider whether the notice of termination should provide reasons, and (in any event) be prepared to defend its decision to dismiss the employee before the ECT.
It is notable that this case was set in the context of probation. While probation periods (during which both parties are entitled to terminate with shorter notice) conventionally allow greater flexibility for employers to evaluate whether new joiners are a good fit for the organisation, the ECT in JIW did not afford that leeway. Instead, it held the employer to the same exacting standard as that when assessing the performance of its permanent employees. Given the ECT’s decision in JIW, employers should comprehensively document, clearly articulate, and holistically justify the performance requirements and appraisal decisions, even during the probation period.
It should also be noted that employees may also have other potential causes of action, in addition to the statutory claim for wrongful dismissal:
- Breach of implied duty of mutual trust and confidence during the term of employment under common law: Where employees have been placed on a performance improvement plan (PIP) that was not intended to provide the employee with a genuine opportunity to improve, that could amount to a breach of the implied duty of mutual trust and confidence (specifically the duty not to behave in an intolerable or wholly unacceptable way), giving rise to a separate cause of action before the Singapore courts.
- Statutory tort of workplace discrimination: Employment decisions in relation to performance appraisals (as well as promotions and demotions) are subject to the anti-discrimination protections under the Singapore Workplace Fairness Act 2025 (WFA). Once the WFA comes into force (anticipated in 2027), employees who were discriminated against due to a protected characteristic in their performance appraisals will have yet another statutory cause of action against their employers. Please refer to our earlier update on the WFA for details: Workplace Fairness – Singapore tables legislation to create new statutory tort of discrimination in the workplace.
If you have questions regarding employee dismissal, internal investigations, disciplinary inquiries, or any other employment matter, please feel free to contact us.
Footnotes
-
The claim limit may be increased from SGD 20,000 to SGD 30,000, if the employee has gone through the Tripartite Mediation Framework or mediations assisted by unions recognised under the Industrial Relations Act 1960.
-
Pursuant to Section 27(2)(b) of the Singapore Employment Claims Act 2016.
-
JIW at [13].
-
JIW at [81], [82], [89].
-
JIW at [18], [33]-[72]. In total, the ECT examined the scores given on 10 individual components, comprising 4 performance goals and the 6 contested competencies.
-
JIW at [85].
-
JIW at [86]-[87].
-
JIW at [19]-[22].
-
The claimant was thus left to navigate a set of qualitative descriptors without any guidance as to how they would be applied to her work in practice, or what she would need to demonstrate to achieve a passing rating. The employer also failed to conduct periodic documented reviews as required by its probation management process. The claimant received her first set of formal feedback on the performance goals only on the day she was informed that she had failed her probation. Periodic documented reviews would have given the claimant clear and sufficient notice of the standards against which she was being assessed and provided the supervisor with specific and documented foundation for the final ratings given. See JIW at [21]-[23], [29], [82], [93].
-
While the supervisor’s instructions were high-level and open-ended, they were not so vague as to be incapable of execution. As an experienced auditor of 15 years, the claimant was in a position to understand the instructions, and to know what producing the work product would require: JIW at [63].
-
JIW at [59]-[67].
-
JIW at [32], [66]-[67].
-
JIW at [33]-[46]; [52]-[56].
-
JIW at [47]-[51]; [57]-[58].
-
The employer also failed to produce evidence of the nature or extent of the alleged formatting deficiencies, such as annotated documents, before-and-after comparisons or specific examples (JIW at [44]).
-
JIW at [68]-[72].
-
JIW at [24].
-
JIW at [25]-[28], [82].
-
E.g., the claimant was reluctant to engage with the process audit assignment and to provide the interim reporting, despite being asked on more than one occasion.
-
JIW at [88].
-
JIW at [96]-[99].
-
JIW at [16].
-
See also JGP v JGQ [2026] SGECT 1 at [79(c)], [91], [A.120].
-
JIW at [16].