Back to Legalflyer

In this article the authors consider the impact of jet fuel volatility (both price increases and supply shortages) on airline profitability and the consequent impact on aviation finance.

Key points

  • Although the aviation industry is proving to be resilient so far in the face of jet fuel price and supply volatility, from a financier’s perspective, concerns regarding a potential future deterioration in the financial performance of airlines might impact the willingness of some financiers to finance aircraft, or lead to the attempted addition of protections in financing documentation.
  • Higher costs and inflation can distort future aircraft valuation forecasts and can increase the residual value risk for financiers or lessors.
  • Engines can generally operate on sustainable aviation fuels blended with Kerosene A jet fuel, but it is not easy to find alternative fuels, in sufficient quantities, which meet the criteria for weight, flammability, energy content and freezing point.

In normal times, an estimated 20.3 million barrels of petroleum and crude oil, or roughly 25 percent of the world maritime oil trade, pass through the Strait of Hormuz every day. Hormuz is the only maritime gateway to the Persian Gulf, from where the major oil producers Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates export most of their oil. Since the start of the conflict in the Middle East, that flow has been cut to virtually zero.

Geopolitical events, such as wars, trade sanctions and political unrest in major energy-producing regions, can drive huge volatility in global crude oil markets. As a result of the conflict, and the blockade of this narrow sea channel, the price of oil, and jet fuel, has substantially increased during this year. Concerns have also been expressed in some regions regarding short and mid-term supply.

It is to be hoped that this situation will improve following the announcement of a memorandum of understanding between the US and Iran which is intended to facilitate the re-opening of the Strait of Hormuz. However, uncertainty remains and it is likely to be some time before the level of pre-conflict oil transit will be restored. Furthermore, it is likely that there may be a time lag between any reduction in the price of crude oil and a reduction in the price of jet fuel, as well as improvements in supply, due to depleted reserves of jet fuel and reduced refinery capacity.

Impact on airline profitability

Increases of fuel price, and limits on supply, inevitably most immediately affect airlines. Before the conflict, according to the International Air Transport Association (IATA), fuel already accounted for around 20-30 percent of the cost of operation. A sudden and unexpected increase in the cost of jet fuel inevitably has a huge impact on the profitability of airlines, for some of whom margins are lean at the best of times.

Airlines have sought to offset some of these increases but the measures available to them are limited. Some are well hedged for the time being, although this varies geographically. Many EU airlines are substantially hedged for 2026 but are subject to price volatilities beyond that. By contrast, US airlines tend to benefit from cheap and plentiful local supply so do not hedge, although even they need to fuel at destination airports which may not be in the US. Fuel surcharges and operational adjustments mitigate the impact, but these can only go so far. In the end, airlines either have to avoid or absorb the additional costs, or pass them on to passengers, with the risk that higher ticket prices impact demand. In addition, whilst a fuel hedging strategy can assist an airline in mitigating the impact of higher fuel pricing, it does not mitigate the problem of a shortage in fuel supply.

As well as the direct impact of an increase in the price of jet fuel on an airline’s cost base, the impact of higher fuel prices on the wider economy impacts airline profitability. Increased fuel prices often lead to inflationary pressures. It is not just airlines, and airlines’ suppliers, which buy fuel – energy prices impact every business. Increased energy costs therefore often lead to price increases which, in turn, can lead to inflation. So, airlines not only feel the impact of increased oil prices directly, but they may also see their own suppliers seeking to increase prices in response to the rising energy costs. In addition, in order to combat inflation, central banks often raise interest rates which impacts the cost of borrowing. Due to the recent progress towards resolution of the conflict with Iran, at the time of writing, many central banks are expected to hold interest rates to their current level. However, this situation is subject to change if inflationary pressures do not ease.

Economic uncertainty can also give rise to currency fluctuations. Airlines tend to be particularly exposed to variations in the value of the US dollar given that the cost of many of their outgoings including fuel costs, maintenance costs and indeed the cost of aircraft are US dollar denominated, whereas an airline’s income will frequently be denominated in other currencies. In the immediate aftermath of the start of the conflict the US dollar gained in strength against major currencies, effectively adding to the financial pressure on many airlines.

In addition, there is also the risk that an economic slowdown leads to a reduced demand for travel, particularly business travel, as businesses try to reduce costs, and in leisure travel, driven by a reduction in disposable income. Nonetheless recent IATA projections indicate that despite the economic turbulence, passenger numbers are still set to increase when compared to 2025 levels, although overall IATA have reduced their profit forecast for airlines in 2026 by half.

Airlines which are well funded are most concerned by the long-term supply issues which could limit their flying programmes. Airlines which are less well funded are more concerned that the oil price will cause financial uncertainties even before the supply issues cause concern.

Airlines are seeking external help to reduce the impact. In some regions, airlines’ lobbying has led to governments taking action to co-ordinate the supply of fuel, alleviate unnecessary costs from both slot legislation (avoiding airlines having to operate routes just to retain their slot rights) and passenger rights (confirming that cancellations caused by fuel concerns are not compensatable), and a reduction of the burden of emission trading schemes.

The impact on aviation finance

The financial performance of airlines is critical to the whole aviation financing ecosystem, whether it is the financing, leasing or operation of aircraft, so it is inevitable that one sees consequences where issues arise which impact that financial performance.

Firstly, from a financier’s perspective, concerns regarding a potential future deterioration in the financial performance of airlines may impact the willingness of some financiers to finance aircraft at all, or may lead to the attempted addition of protections in financing documentation, such as conditions precedent to drawdown relating to market deterioration which could enable a financier to refuse to advance funds in certain circumstances. Any future withdrawal of commercial financiers from aircraft finance is likely to lead to an increase in borrowing costs as competition for financing mandates decreases, and to demand for alternative forms of financing such as the export credit supported financing of aircraft.

Higher costs and inflation can also distort future aircraft valuation forecasts and can increase the residual value risk for financiers or lessors, namely the problem caused by equipment losing value more quickly than expected by the end of the lease term. This can affect financiers’ and lessors’ appetite for particular asset types, with the preference being for aircraft which will keep their value, and which will be easier to remarket in the future if necessary. It may also affect required loan to value ratios in aircraft financing transactions thus reducing the amount which a financier is willing to lend. To some extent, the risk of value deterioration has been offset by production delays at aircraft manufacturers (also exacerbated by supply chain difficulties), meaning that demand for new aircraft has continued to outstrip supply thus far, however any continuation of inflated jet fuel prices may affect this in future.

In addition, a deterioration in an airline’s profitability could mean that it is at greater risk of defaulting on its financing and leasing transactions. As a consequence, transactions may need to be restructured in order to facilitate the ability of the airline to meet its commitments or, in the worst-case scenario, that events of default are triggered and enforcement action taken. This can lead to substantial financial losses for a lessor or financier in an environment where aircraft values are reduced and opportunities to remarket the aircraft are more limited.

Whether or not an event of default has occurred is a matter of contractual interpretation. Typically, an event of default such as a non-payment event is easier to establish than reliance on an event of default relating to a more general deterioration in performance or in the market such as a material adverse change provision. It is therefore likely that lessors and financiers will want to monitor their portfolios closely and use information covenants in lease and loan documentation to obtain any necessary information regarding financial performance and the location of aircraft and engines (which often move between aircraft in an airline’s fleet). A lessor or financier may also want to monitor an airline’s financial exposure to entities such as air traffic control authorities or maintenance providers who may be able to assert a lien over an aircraft for non-payment.

From an airline’s perspective, the current economic volatility may influence its choice of financing for any acquisition of new aircraft. In times of uncertainty airlines strive to preserve cash and reduce their own exposure to residual value risk, which may make airlines consider taking aircraft on an operating lease rather than purchasing new aircraft. This may actually increase opportunities for aircraft leasing companies in an environment where demand for new more fuel-efficient aircraft remains high and there is a shortage in supply of aircraft. Airlines may also want to explore options to increase certainty as to their financing costs such as opting for fixed interest or fixed lease rates (or entering into interest rate hedging arrangements) to reduce their exposure to fluctuating interest rates.

If the elevated cost of jet fuel continues, it may lead to airlines revisiting fleeting decisions. For instance, airlines may choose to make do with existing aircraft for longer, or defer purchases of new aircraft, unless by taking new aircraft there is a substantial saving in terms of fuel burn. Airlines might also consider a different mix of routes, and possibly different aircraft to serve those routes. Some aircraft may be grounded and stored pending an easing of tensions and a resumption of full flying programmes. This could obviously impact aircraft values in the longer term – particularly those of older aircraft.

Is there an alternative to Kerosene A jet fuel?

In times of potential crisis over oil and jet fuel supply, one might think that sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) – the demand for which to date has been driven more by regulatory pressure, and emissions and blending targets, than economic advantages – might be the answer as a strategic hedge against commodity market shocks.

Engines can generally operate on alternative fuels blended with Kerosene A jet fuel, but it is not easy to find fuels, in sufficient quantities, which meet the criteria for weight, flammability, energy content and freezing point. As a result of these factors, and SAF’s availability and cost, SAF still only accounts for a very small percentage of global jet fuel, even though the emissions attributable to SAF are considered re-absorbed and therefore are not subject to emissions trading schemes. In terms of cost, SAF remains more expensive that jet fuel, but economic shocks such as the one experienced this year may further increase the interest in SAF as a hedge against kerosene products, given the consequences for energy security.

However, for the time being the aviation industry remains very largely reliant on oil, and while that continues it will be susceptible to shocks as have been felt during this year’s crisis. If in due course SAF becomes more affordable, and more plentiful, it could help the industry ride such shocks. These are all factors which those financing the aviation industry will need to stay on top of.

It is to be hoped that the recent progress made in resolving the Iranian conflict will lead to the re-opening of the Strait of Hormuz and a consequent reduction in the oil price – indeed, at the time of writing, we have already seen this reduction start to occur. However, even if this progress continues, it may be longer before this leads to a consequent reduction in the price of jet fuel and a full restoration of supply. Nonetheless the aviation industry and the finance ecosystem which supports it, is used to weathering economic storms and continues to demonstrate its resilience in the face of these issues.

This article was first published in the August/September issue of Butterworths Journal of International Banking and Financial Law

Contact