In Baron Real Estate Investments Ltd v Tri-Arrow Industrial Recovery Inc, (Baron), the Alberta Court of Appeal restored an action that had been dismissed for long delay under rule 4.33 of the Alberta Rules of Court (allowing dismissal for a delay of three or more years). The court held that the chambers judge erred by effectively narrowing the live issues in the action and conducting a merits-based screening more appropriate to a summary judgment application. The decision offers important guidance on what constitutes a "significant advance" in an action and what does not belong in the rule 4.33 analysis.

Background

The appellant, Baron, leased land to the respondent Tri-Arrow for hazardous and non-hazardous waste disposal and treatment operations. After Tri-Arrow's shares were sold to Stericycle, a dispute arose, and Baron terminated the lease in 2014. Baron sued Stericycle and the respondent Riteway, for over C$14 million in combined damages arising from alleged land contamination and related claims.

Affidavits of records were exchanged between 2016 and 2018, and questioning was scheduled for September 2020. Baron's counsel postponed the questioning to prepare a supplemental affidavit of records, which was ultimately served in March 2021. The supplemental records included a substantial volume of Tri-Arrow/Stericycle documents, including employee communications, incident reports, spill reports, photographs, and waste tracking spreadsheets, that Stericycle itself had never produced and could not confirm it possessed.

Stericycle and Riteway applied to dismiss the action for long delay under rule 4.33. The applications judge found the supplemental affidavit of records constituted a significant advance and dismissed the applications. On appeal, the applications judge’s decision was reversed as the chambers judge found that the supplemental records addressed only "peripheral issues" because they did not go to what she identified as the "central issue," being the extent of land contamination and cost of remediation.

The test for significant advance

The Court of Appeal allowed Baron's further appeal and restored the action.

The Court of Appeal's analysis provides a clear articulation of the rule 4.33 framework. Assessing whether a step constitutes a significant advance requires asking whether it moves the lawsuit forward in an essential way, having regard to its nature, value, importance, and quality, with the genuineness and timing of the step also being relevant.

The key question is whether anything that happened in the relevant period increased, by a measurable degree, the likelihood the parties or a court would have sufficient information to better assess the merits and either settle or adjudicate the action. Steps that narrow the issues, complete the discovery of documents and information, or clarify the parties' positions may all constitute a significant advance. Each piece of litigation is unique, and the content, value, and timing of the advance must be assessed within the context of that lawsuit.

Importantly, this is not a summary judgment standard. The court was explicit that a significant advance "does not have to be so definitive that it would support an application for summary judgment" (para 20). There is a meaningful distinction between assessing an evidentiary record for summary judgment purposes and the qualitative assessment required to determine whether an action has truly died. Rule 4.33 is designed to dismiss such actions, not to serve as a vehicle for evaluating the merits of a party's claim.

Supplemental affidavits of records can reset the clock

In this case, the chambers judge accepted that the supplemental records were relevant and material to issues raised in the pleadings but concluded the records went only to "peripheral issues" because they did not address contamination and remediation costs. However, the Court of Appeal found this reasoning amounted to a merits-based assessment that had no place in the rule 4.33 analysis. The chambers judge was effectively persuaded to summarily determine Baron's claim, concluding the supplemental records did not significantly advance the action because they did not contain information required to resist summary dismissal.

The court distilled the proper approach in straightforward terms: "If all allegations raised and denied in the pleadings were to proceed to trial, the supplemental records would have significance in deciding the case." It was not for the chambers judge to narrow the live issues or forecast how the case would be decided in the context of the rule 4.33 applications. The respondents remain free to apply for summary dismissal of the claims against them if they wish to do so, but that is a separate proceeding with a separate standard.

Timing and genuineness of disclosure steps

The court also addressed the chambers judge's finding that Baron ought to have produced the supplemental records earlier. While the chambers judge accepted the step was genuine and not a last-minute effort to keep the action alive, she found Baron's explanation for the delay in production was inadequate, noting that most of the supplemental records predated the original affidavit of records.

The Court of Appeal held the chambers judge overstated how much of the supplemental record was in Baron's possession before its original affidavit of records. The creation date of records does not necessarily correspond with Baron's possession date, particularly where many of the documents were Tri-Arrow/Stericycle records that Baron received incrementally from a former facility manager between 2016 and late 2019. The court found Baron's explanation, together with the genuineness of the step, was sufficient to support a finding of significant advance.

That said, the court was careful to note the result should not be taken as condoning the pace of the litigation. The court directed the parties to agree on a litigation plan or apply for directions to move the matter along expeditiously.

Takeaways for litigants

Baron is a useful decision for parties on both sides of long delay applications. It clarifies the boundaries of the rule 4.33 analysis and offers the following practical guidance:

  • The rule 4.33 test is not a merits screening. Courts considering whether a step significantly advances an action should not evaluate the strength of the underlying claim, narrow the issues beyond what the pleadings disclose, or forecast the merits of the claim. The question is whether the step moved the proceeding forward in an essential way, not whether it would withstand summary judgment scrutiny.
  • Genuineness matters. The court's analysis reinforced that whether a step was genuine, as opposed to a last-minute tactic to keep an action alive, remains a relevant consideration in the rule 4.33 framework.
  • Delay is still taken seriously. Although the appeal was allowed, the court emphasized that its decision should not be read as excusing delay. Parties in protracted litigation should expect to be directed to agree on litigation plans or seek court directions to advance their matters.

Contact