This article was co-authored with Jemilla Lister.
In September 2026, the Climate Change Authority (Authority) released its 2026 Review (Review) of the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 (Cth) (the Act), which assesses the operation of the Australian Carbon Credit Unit (ACCU) Scheme. This is the Authority’s fifth review of the ACCU Scheme.
The Review reaffirms the Authority’s previous findings 2023 Review of the ACCU Scheme | Climate Change Authority. and the conclusions of the 2022 Independent Review of Australian Carbon Credit Units (Chubb Review)https://www.dcceew.gov.au/climate-change/emissions-reduction/accu-scheme/reviews-and-reforms/independent-review-accus that the ACCU Scheme is fundamentally sound and remains an important component of Australia’s climate policy framework.
The Review considers how the ACCU Scheme can continue to support credible domestic emissions reductions while maintaining scheme integrity, market confidence and investment certainty. The Authority does not recommend any fundamental redesign of the ACCU Scheme. Rather, the Review focuses on targeted reforms intended to address residual gaps and strengthen confidence in the ACCU Scheme.
Key takeaways
- Scheme integrity reaffirmed: The Authority concludes that the ACCU Scheme remains fundamentally sound, with recent reforms strengthening governance, transparency and integrity.
- No major policy reset recommended: The Review recommends six targeted reforms focused on permanence settings, public value, market transparency and method development, rather than blanket changes to the ACCU Scheme.
- Changed demand dynamics: Safeguard Mechanism compliance has replaced the Australian Government as the principal source of ACCU demand, fundamentally changing the role of the ACCU market.
- 25-year permanence under increased scrutiny: The Authority recommends further consideration of whether ACCUs generated from eligible offsets projects with 25-year permanence obligations should continue to be accepted for Safeguard Mechanism compliance.
- Greater focus on public and First Nations benefits: The Authority recommends that any future Australian Government purchasing of ACCUs should prioritise projects delivering credible public and First Nations benefits.
- Enhanced transparency and registry functionality: The Review recommends improved access to project-level and unit-level information, and greater interoperability to support buyer due diligence and market confidence.
- Method development reform: The Authority recommends publication of a forward method development roadmap and improvements to the efficiency, capacity and predictability of the method development process.
Overview of the Review
The Review is organised around thematic chapters, each examining a distinct aspect of the ACCU Scheme. We summarise below the key findings and recommendations.
ACCU Scheme's role in achieving Australia's emissions reduction targets
The Review examines the evolving role of the ACCU Scheme within Australia's broader climate policy framework. The Authority notes that the ACCU Scheme is no longer Australia's primary economy-wide emissions reduction policy and now operates alongside the Safeguard Mechanism and sector-specific policies as part of a broader suite of emissions reduction measures.
The Authority emphasises that ACCUs continue to play an important role in supporting Australia's emissions reduction objectives. ACCUs provide compliance flexibility under the Safeguard Mechanism and can reduce overall compliance costs, while voluntary and Australian Government purchasing of ACCUs contributes directly to Australia's national emissions reduction targets.
The Review also considers the types of activities best suited to ACCU crediting. The Authority considers that the ACCU Scheme is most effective where activities can clearly satisfy the Offsets Integrity Standards, deliver scalable and measurable abatement, are technologically mature and provide durable emissions reductions or removals. Activities that do not satisfy these characteristics may be more appropriately supported through other policy mechanisms.
Looking forward, the Authority notes that Safeguard Mechanism demand is unlikely to fully realise the land sector's long-term sequestration potential, suggesting that additional policy measures will be required to unlock the full contribution of the land sector to Australia's net zero objectives. The Review also highlights the increasing importance of durable carbon removals and stronger alignment between the longevity of emissions and the abatement used to offset them as Australia progresses towards net zero.
Permanence, durability and ACCU Scheme confidence
The ACCU Scheme currently permits sequestration projects to choose either a 25-year or 100-year permanence period. Projects that choose a 25-year permanence period receive fewer ACCUs, reflecting the application of a permanence period discount (currently 20%), and are not required to maintain carbon stores beyond the end of the chosen permanence period.
The Authority identifies permanence as one of the key issues requiring further examination as the ACCU Scheme evolves. In particular, it notes the increased use of 25-year permanence ACCUs for Safeguard Mechanism compliance, accounting for 19% of Safeguard Mechanism surrenders in 2023-24 and 22% in 2024-25. Such ACCUs also comprise approximately 26% of ACCUs currently held by Safeguard entities. The Authority considers that the growing use of 25-year permanence ACCUs for compliance purposes raises questions as to whether the emissions reduction outcomes delivered by those ACCUs are sufficiently durable, particularly as demand from Safeguard facilities is expected to increase significantly over time.
The Authority also notes that the Australian Government has proposed legislative amendments that would allow eligible projects to transition from a 25-year to a 100-year permanence period.
The Authority has previously suggested that a ratio of 4:1 (that is, four credits from 25-year projects to equate to one 100-year credit, reflecting a 75% discount) would be a ‘robust, very cautious setting’2026 Review of the ACCU Scheme | Climate Change Authority, p. 34. that guards against full reversal. Some stakeholders have also suggested allowing projects to extend their permanence commitments incrementally over time, rather than requiring a 100-year commitment upfront.
Against this backdrop, the Authority makes two recommendations directed at assessing whether current permanence settings remain appropriate and whether further reforms may be required.
Recommendation 1: Complete and publish the first assessment of the risk of reversal buffer and permanence period discount by the end of 2027.
The Review recommends that this assessment should consider whether the current settings remain appropriate in light of climate-related risks, reversal events and evolving market conditions, including whether the discount applied to 25-year permanence projects remains appropriate.
Recommendation 2: Through the 2026-27 Safeguard Mechanism Review,~~2026-27 Safeguard Mechanism Review - Department of Climate Change, Energy, Environment and Water.~~assess whether ACCUs generated from 25-year permanence projects provide sufficient durability for Safeguard Mechanism compliance.
The Review recommends that the Government should consider options for better aligning the durability of ACCUs used for compliance with the longevity of the emissions being offset, together with appropriate transition arrangements if changes are required.
Participation, equity and public benefits
The Authority emphasises that, in addition to the ACCU Scheme delivering emissions reductions, it can also generate significant broader public benefits, including biodiversity outcomes, improved land management, First Nations economic participation, regional development and community resilience. However, as Safeguard Mechanism compliance has become a key driver of ACCU demand, market participants are increasingly focused on procuring the lowest-cost ACCUs, meaning these broader benefits may not be adequately recognised or rewarded. Accordingly, the Authority supports future Australian Government purchasing of ACCUs being directed towards projects that deliver credible public and First Nations benefits.
A central focus of this theme is First Nations participation in the ACCU Scheme. The Authority identifies First Nations-led carbon projects as an important source of economic, environmental and social benefits. While the Authority supports the Australian Government's proposed reforms to native title consent requirements,Consultations open on proposed amendment to the ACCU Scheme | Norton Rose Fulbright Australia it acknowledges that stakeholders continue to advocate for stronger incorporation of free, prior and informed consent principles and improved benefit-sharing arrangements.
The Review also highlights the role of carbon farming in supporting regional and rural communities by providing additional revenue streams, supporting business diversification and improving climate resilience.
More broadly, the Authority considers that stronger integration of regional planning frameworks could help align projects with local priorities and improve community support for projects. The Review also identifies opportunities for complementary carbon and biodiversity outcomes through participation in both the ACCU Scheme and the Nature Repair Market, provided robust safeguards are implemented to maintain additionality and avoid double counting.
Consistent with these observations, the Authority considers that future Australian Government ACCU purchasing should be used to better recognise and support projects that deliver broader public value, including First Nations, environmental and community outcomes that may not otherwise be rewarded by the market.
Recommendation 3: Any future Australian Government purchasing of ACCUs should prioritise projects with credible public and First Nations benefits, supported by clear criteria and guardrails.
Market settings and investment confidence
The Authority observes that the ACCU market is entering a period of significant transition, driven by the Safeguard Mechanism reforms, increasing compliance demand and growing interest in the role ACCUs may play in Australia's post-2030 emissions reduction pathway. While the Authority does not recommend any immediate changes to market settings, it identifies a range of policy options that could materially affect future market dynamics, including accelerated method development, stricter Safeguard Mechanism baselines and decline rates, discounting ACCUs used for compliance, limits on ACCU usage, expanded Australian Government purchasing, changes to cost-containment measures and broader Safeguard Mechanism coverage.
A key theme emerging from stakeholder feedback was the importance of transparency and access to information. The Authority notes that, although the Clean Energy Regulator (CER) and Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (DCCEEW) have implemented a number of transparency improvements in recent years, market participants continue to face challenges accessing, comparing and reusing information about projects and units. Stakeholders identified a need for clearer and more accessible information regarding project characteristics, ACCU attributes, issuance, holdings and transactions to support buyer due diligence, informed investment decisions and to strengthen market confidence. In particular, the Authority notes that certain attributes, such as a project’s permanence period, may be identifiable through project records but are not readily observable at the individual unit level within the Australian National Registry of Emissions Units (Registry).
The Authority also highlights Registry functionality and interoperability as increasingly important as the market matures. It notes the CER's ongoing work to improve connectivity between the Registry, trading platforms, market intermediaries and external data services, with enhanced interoperability expected to improve market efficiency, transparency and accessibility.
The Review also considers concerns raised by stakeholders regarding potential land-use trade-offs associated with growing ACCU demand. While some submissions suggested that projects may compete with agricultural production and affect regional communities, the Authority found no evidence of widespread displacement of high-value agricultural land at a national scale. However, it notes that land-use pressures are arising from multiple sources, including renewable energy developments, transmission infrastructure, nature repair initiatives and emerging industries, and concludes that integrated monitoring and planning will become increasingly important. The Authority intends to examine these broader land-use issues further as part of its 2026 Annual Progress Advice.
While the Authority discusses a range of policy issues that may influence future market development, its sole recommendation under this theme is directed towards improving market transparency and access to information.
Recommendation 4: Give buyers clearer information about carbon credits they are buying.
Build on CER register, data services and Registry reforms by improving access to detailed, standardised and reusable project, unit and market information by:
- improving visibility of material ACCU attributes and project-level information relevant to due diligence and valuation across the Project registry and the Registry;
- improving the accessibility, comparability and reusability of project, unit, holdings and transaction information; and
- progressing any legislative, regulatory or system changes needed to support modern registry interoperability and secure system-to-system functionality.
Method development
The Authority identifies method development as the ACCU Scheme's principal supply-side lever, noting that only activities covered by an approved method can generate ACCUs. While acknowledging recent reforms to the method development framework, including the proponent-led development model and improved transparency measures, the Authority considers that further improvements are required to provide greater certainty regarding the future pipeline of methods and projects.
The Review notes that a growing proportion of future ACCU supply will need to come from new projects, as issuance from many existing projects is expected to decline over time. This increases the importance of maintaining a pipeline of new and updated methods capable of supporting project development and attracting investment. However, the Authority does not consider there to be an immediate need to expand the range of available methods. Rather, it identifies a need for improved forward planning and greater visibility regarding future method development priorities.
Stakeholders continue to express concerns regarding long development timeframes, limited transparency and resourcing constraints. The Review notes that new methods typically require between 18 months and more than three years to progress from prioritisation to finalisation, while remaking existing methods generally takes at least 18 months. The Authority considers that greater visibility of method development priorities, timelines and key dependencies would improve market certainty and investment confidence.
The Review also highlights a number of method-specific developments likely to influence future ACCU supply. These include the expiry of the Human-Induced Regeneration (HIR) method, ongoing delays in the finalisation of the Integrated Farm and Land Management (IFLM) method (with a final draft expected for ERAC consideration by the end of 2026), uncertainty regarding future soil carbon issuance, and potential increases in supply from updated Savanna Fire Management methods and landfill gas methods.
The Authority also identifies opportunities to improve the efficiency and predictability of the method development process through enhanced project management, earlier identification of bottlenecks, improved coordination between DCCEEW, the Emissions Reduction Assurance Committee (ERAC), the CER and project proponents, and appropriate resourcing. It further notes that external legal drafting support could be utilised where drafting capacity is constrained, provided existing governance and assurance mechanisms are maintained.
Importantly, the Authority does not recommend changing the legislative status of ACCU methods. Rather, its focus is on improving strategic planning and delivery within the existing framework while preserving the governance arrangements that underpin the integrity and credibility of the ACCU Scheme.
Recommendation 5: Publish and maintain a forward method development and review roadmap. This would:
- provide guidance on the characteristics of activities likely to be suited to ACCU crediting and, without limiting the proponent-led process, signal where future proposals could support the role of the scheme, projected demand and broader policy objectives;
- provide a forward view of development timelines, key dependencies and decision points across the method work program;
- include risk-based triggers for reviewing existing methods, including evidence of eroding additionality, measurement issues, climate-related risks, market leakage risks or changes in relevant laws, standards or common practice; and
- support timely consideration of whether methods need to be varied, suspended or revoked to maintain integrity.
Recommendation 6: Improve the efficiency, capacity and predictability of the ACCU method development process. This would involve:
- monitoring and reporting progress against method development project plans and indicative timeframes;
- addressing process, resourcing and coordination constraints in method development, variation and remake as early as possible;
- improving coordination across agencies and proponents involved in the method development process;
- ensuring method development functions are adequately resourced, including considering the use of additional sources of qualified external legal drafting support where appropriate.
Next steps
The Authority’s recommendations will be considered by the Australian Government. Although the Review does not propose any immediate or fundamental changes to the ACCU Scheme, it identifies a number of areas that are likely to shape future policy and regulatory developments.
Other key developments to watch include:
- the 2026–27 Safeguard Mechanism review, which will consider both post-2030 baseline decline rates and the treatment of 25-year permanence ACCUs for compliance;
Safeguard Mechanism Review: Consultation paper summary and key implications for industry | Global law firm | Norton Rose Fulbright. - finalisation of the IFLM method, with a final draft expected for ERAC consideration by the end of 2026; and
- progression of the proposed amendments to the Act.
Consultation opens on proposed amendments to the ACCU Scheme | Australia | Global law firm | Norton Rose Fulbright.
We will continue to monitor these developments and provide updates as they occur.