Master trusts, group personal pensions and the larger single employer pension schemes will have to submit extensive performance data, compare that with market comparators and publish VFM ratings in November 2028. The rest of the DC market will follow in 2029. A poor rating could mean the end for a scheme. Here's what we know so far.

The new Value for Money regime

Under a new Value for Money (VFM) regime, trustees and providers will have to assess the performance of their defined contribution (DC) arrangements against comparator arrangements and publish a rating indicating whether their arrangement delivers good value for members. The first ratings for larger schemes and group personal pensions are expected in November 2028.

The FCA is leading on the design work for the VFM framework, working with the DWP and the Pensions Regulator (TPR). Following preliminary consultations in August 2024 and January 2026, the July 2026 consultation has fleshed out the broad architecture in draft regulations and FCA Handbook rules.

How will the assessment work?

Step 1: Collect, submit and compare data

Trustees and providers will collect and submit data across four areas through TPR's new digital service:

  • Investment performance (historical and forward-looking data).
  • Asset allocation.
  • Costs and charges.
  • Quality of service.

However the detail of that data is not yet final. The regulators are still refining the detail of the report, and particularly how to deal with performance metrics on changes of arrangement. Thinking on the method proposed for statistically connecting historical investment performance data across different funds or periods (known as ‘chain linking’) has evolved significantly and is a core focus for the July 2026 consultation paper.

After the data submission deadline (March 31), TPR will produce comparator group data drawn from all submissions. Two comparator groups will be used:

  • Arrangements in the 30 years to retirement cohort will be compared against the wider commercial market.
  • At-retirement arrangements (0 years to retirement) will be compared against other arrangements targeting the same retirement outcome (e.g. drawdown, annuity purchase or cash).

Step 2: Assess value

The first step will be to assess investment performance against the comparator data to produce a provisional finding on whether the arrangement is delivering value. Quality of service and service costs are then considered. These factors can downgrade a provisional finding of value but cannot, generally, offset poor investment performance. For occupational pension schemes, the trustees or managers will undertake the assessment, and for group personal pension schemes, IGCs (independent governance committees) will have that duty.

Step 3: Finalise the assessment and assign a rating

Before assigning a final rating, trustees and IGCs can take account of features of their arrangement not reflected in the comparator data, such as guarantees, safeguarded benefits and certain legacy features.

A final VFM rating is then assigned and an assessment report explaining how that rating was reached must be submitted through TPR's digital service by October 31. The data, report and rating will be made publicly available by November 7, each year.

The available ratings

The consultation proposes four ratings:

  • Dark green: delivering strong value.
  • Light green: delivering value, although improvements could still be made.
  • Amber: not currently delivering value, but capable of improvement within three years.
  • Red: not delivering value and not expected to improve sufficiently within a reasonable period.

The consequences of a rating

The 2028 cycle will be a trial run, with no consequences from bad ratings. For later rounds, both amber and red ratings would trigger notification obligations to regulators, participating employers, trustees and providers:

  • Amber rated arrangements would generally be required to prepare an improvement plan setting out how value will be improved or, where appropriate, how members will be moved to a better-value arrangement.
  • Red rated arrangements would be required to prepare an action plan and would generally be expected to transfer members to a value-rated arrangement, provided this is in members' best interests.

TPR and the FCA will not have the resources to test every rating, but it seems clear that the regulators will be tracking sufficiently to act if the data does not seem to support the rating given. There will also be new duties on trustee boards to ensure that trustees / trustee directors have the skills and knowledge necessary to ensure VFM performance is improved where required. VFM ratings, data and reports will be publicly accessible once published, enabling members and the wider public to review performance.

Which schemes and arrangements are relevant?

The VFM framework will apply to arrangements in both occupational schemes regulated by TPR and contract-based arrangements regulated by the FCA.

In-scope:

  • Master trusts.
  • Single employer DC schemes.
  • DC arrangements in hybrid schemes (but see below).
  • Group personal pensions and other contract-based pension arrangements.
  • Arrangements closed to new employers (‘legacy arrangements’).
  • Certain bespoke arrangements established for a particular employer.

Out of scope:

  • Defined benefit (DB) schemes (where a scheme provides DB and DC benefits, the framework applies only to the DC element).
  • In-house additional voluntary contribution arrangements.
  • Collective defined contribution arrangements (though this will be kept under review).
  • Executive pension schemes (broadly, a scheme where the company is the only employer and sole trustee and the members are either current or former directors, including at least 1/3 of current directors).
  • Small self-administered schemes.
  • Schemes that are winding up.

Other than quality of service which will be assessed at a scheme or platform level, the framework will apply at arrangement level rather than scheme level, meaning different commercial propositions using the same platform, umbrella scheme or default fund could receive different ratings.

For in-scope schemes, the framework will apply to:

  • All default arrangements (where contributions to an automatic enrolment scheme are invested without the member having made an active choice).
  • Certain legacy "quasi-default" arrangements (broadly, pre-automatic enrolment arrangements used by most of an employer's members and treated similarly to a default arrangement).

Provided in either case the arrangement has either:

  • At least 1,000 members accumulating benefits.
  • Fewer than 1,000 members, but it is the scheme's only arrangement or its largest arrangement.

The rules on what schemes and arrangements are in-scope can be complicated, and there are other limited exceptions not detailed here. If you are unsure whether a particular arrangement is in-scope, TPR’s flowchart is a useful starting point.

When will the VFM framework start?

2028: Data collection (all in-scope arrangements)

Trustees and providers of all in-scope arrangements will need to:

  • Collect VFM data from July 1, 2027, to December 31, 2027.
  • Submit VFM data through TPR's VFM digital service by March 31, 2028.

2028: Full assessment (master trusts and larger single employer schemes)

The trustees of all DC master trusts and single employer trusts with 50,000 or more members, plus the IGCs of all firm-designed, open, multi-employer contract-based schemes (i.e. group personal pensions) will then need to:

  • Complete a full VFM assessment.
  • Assign a VFM rating.
  • Submit an assessment report and rating by October 31, 2028.
  • Have the data, rating and report published in November 2028.

2029: Full framework (all in-scope arrangements)

The full VFM framework will apply to all remaining trustees and other providers of in-scope arrangements from 2029:

  • March 31, 2029: deadline for submitting VFM data.
  • October 31, 2029: deadline for submitting assessment report and rating.
  • November 7, 2029: data and rating published.

What do we know about the VFM digital service?

TPR will operate a new digital service to support the VFM framework. The service will be used by trustees and providers to submit VFM data and complete key steps in the assessment process.

TPR has confirmed that during the January to March reporting window, data will not need to be submitted in a single upload. Information can be entered directly into the service, uploaded via an XLSX template or submitted through an API (application programming interface). Automated validation checks will identify missing information, formatting issues and obvious inconsistencies, but will not verify the accuracy of the underlying data.

Access will be restricted to authorised users. TPR and the FCA will be able to access VFM data and assessment ratings at both arrangement and aggregate level.

What to do now to prepare for VFM?

  • Identify which arrangements are likely to be in scope.
  • Understand what data will be required and whether it can be obtained from administrators, providers, investment managers and other advisers.
  • Identify any gaps in existing data, systems or processes that would hinder the collection and submission of data.
  • Consider the governance and oversight arrangements that will be needed to support future VFM assessments.

Our view

VFM is not a new concept for trustees and providers of DC arrangements. Chair’s statements and IGC reports have had to include an assessment of value for members of charges, fees and costs since 2015, with additional elements added over time. Trustees of sub-£100 million occupational DC arrangements have had to go through a comparison process since 2021. The existing requirements for chairs’ statements and IGC reports will not automatically fall away, but are being reconsidered in the light of the new VFM framework.

The new VFM framework will be a very real step change in terms of the amount of data, the market comparison structure and the implications of a poor rating.

Arguably the main risk to schemes (apart from the cost of the process) is public comparison, rather than regulatory intervention. From November 2028, employers, advisers, savers and competitors will be able to see how arrangements compare with the wider market. For many trustees and providers, the reputational impact of an arrangement with an amber or red rating may be more significant than the formal regulatory consequences that follow.

For employers, a poor rating could create difficult decisions, particularly where legacy contractual commitments, consultation obligations or protected benefits make a change of provider complicated.

For trustees and providers, the immediate challenge is working with fund platforms, asset managers and scheme administrators to gather the sheer volume of data. Deciding what action to take where the results are disappointing will come later.

card-grid-item, aem-sourced
UK Pensions Briefing | Mandatory default pension benefit solutions for DC pots: What do we know so far?
/en/insights/publications/2026/09/uk-pensions-briefing-mandatory-default-pension-benefit-solutions-for-dc-pots
card-grid-item, aem-sourced
UK Pensions Briefing | Scale requirements for DC pension arrangements: What do we know so far?
/en/insights/publications/2026/09/uk-pensions-briefing-scale-requirements-for-dc-pension-arrangements-what-do-we-know-so-far
card-grid-item, aem-sourced
DC round-up
/en/insights/publications/2026/09/dc-round-up

Contact