In Clinique médicale Lacroix c. Dermago inc., a decision likely to attract the attention of organizations conducting internal investigations or involved in commercial litigation, the Superior Court of Quebec dismissed a lawsuit in which Clinique médicale Lacroix (Clinic) claimed nearly C$10 million, on the grounds that the Clinic had violated the privacy rights of opposing parties and obtained and consulted information protected by solicitor-client privilege. The court concluded that this conduct irremediably compromised the fairness of the judicial debate, justifying the complete dismissal of the action.

Background

The dispute involved the Clinic and former collaborators, including two dermatologists who had left the Clinic to operate their own dermatology clinic. Suspecting, in particular, the diversion of clients and the appropriation of confidential information, the Clinic searched computer workstations previously used by certain respondents. These steps led it to access personal Gmail and Google Drive accounts containing, in particular, communications between these respondents and their lawyers regarding the litigation.

The documents consulted on several occasions included statements of fact prepared for the legal mandate, legal opinions, strategic recommendations, correspondence with prosecutors, as well as detailed fee accounts.

The decision addresses a question rarely examined so directly: What remedy should be applied when a party does not merely obtain a privileged document, but acquires detailed knowledge of its opponent's legal strategy?

The court emphasized that the exclusion of evidence provided for in article 2858 C.C.Q. does not necessarily exhaust the powers of the court. Obtaining and using protected information may also constitute conduct that is vexatious and an abuse of procedure within the meaning of articles 51 et seq. of the C.P.C., which allow for imposing more significant sanctions when the circumstances justify it.

The problem, therefore, does not lie solely in possessing documents that may be excluded from evidence. The knowledge acquired may influence the preparation of the file, the procedural strategy, the choice of witnesses, or the conduct of examinations, even if the documents are never entered into evidence.

Adopting an approach based on the presumption of harm

Relying in particular on Celanese Canada Inc. v. Murray Demolition Corp. and Continental Currency Exchange Canada Inc. v. Sprott, the court applies a three-step test to determine:

  • If the opposing party obtained access to relevant information protected by solicitor-client privilege.
  • Whether this party rebutted the resulting presumption of prejudice by clear and convincing evidence.
  • What remedy is necessary to protect the fairness of the trial and the integrity of the administration of justice.

The court concluded that access to protected documents was clearly demonstrated and the presumption of prejudice applied. The Clinic did not clearly and convincingly demonstrate it had not become aware of the protected information or, otherwise, that the information consulted was not likely to provide an advantage in the litigation.

A dismissal of action deemed necessary

After examining various corrective measures, the court concluded that none would restore the balance between the parties. The information had been consulted by several Clinic representatives holding central roles in conducting the litigation, including executives, in-house counsel, and external counsel. Once this knowledge was acquired, it became virtually impossible to offset its effects.

The court therefore concluded that dismissing the action constitutes, in the particular circumstances of the case, the only adequate remedy to preserve the integrity of the judicial process. It also ordered the destruction of the documents and the Clinic to pay C$150,000 in punitive damages and C$150,000 in compensatory damages for the fees and disbursements incurred by the respondents.

Key practical takeaways

This decision contains several important lessons for companies, their executives, and their legal teams.

  1. Technical access does not create a legal right of access: The fact that a personal account is accessible from a company-owned device does not mean the organization may freely access its content. Neither does the presence of personal information in a professional account eliminate reasonable expectations of privacy.
  2. Internal investigations must be managed carefully: When an organization suspects the appropriation of confidential information or acts of unfair competition, investigative steps should be guided from the outset by considerations relating to privacy, electronic evidence, and solicitor-client privilege.
  3. Appropriate judicial mechanisms remain available: The court emphasized that a party who believes it has been a victim of misappropriation of information has several legal remedies available, including requests for the production of documents, examinations for discovery or, in certain cases, an Anton Piller order. The use of unilateral measures that risk compromising fundamental rights entails considerable risks.
  4. The impacts may be much more severe than the exclusion of evidence: This decision serves as a reminder that a breach of solicitor-client privilege can lead to impacts that go far beyond excluding illegally obtained documents. In certain circumstances, it can lead to the complete dismissal of the legal action as well as the awarding of compensatory damages, or even punitive damages.
  5. The frequency of access and its purpose increase the risk: Further searches, after the litigation was initiated, to obtain new evidence, played a significant role in assessing the intentional, vexatious, and abusive nature of the conduct.
  6. Immediate action must be taken when potentially privileged information is discovered: The review must cease, access must be restricted, the lawyers concerned must be notified, and independent protective measures must be considered. A sorting performed by the representatives or lawyers of the interested party does not necessarily offset the prejudice.

Conclusion

Clinique médicale Lacroix c. Dermago inc. is an important reminder of the privileged position that solicitor-client privilege holds within the Canadian legal system. Above all, it illustrates that once the opposing legal strategy has been consulted by the central actors in a dispute, removing documents is not necessarily sufficient to restore the fairness of the proceedings.

For organizations conducting internal investigations or preparing for litigation, this case demonstrates the importance of adopting rigorous, proportionate, and legally framed evidence collection methods from the earliest stages, as well as precise protocols to protect personal and privileged information.

Contact