The UK First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT)’s recent decision in Lifeplus Europe Ltd v The Commissioners for His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2026] UKFTT 797 (TC) clarifies the bounds of HMRC’s power to request documents through a taxpayer information notice issued under Schedule 36, Finance Act 2008.  Given the breadth of many Schedule 36 notices, the decision is a useful reminder that there are two key tests to be met: the information sought must be “reasonably required” for the purposes of checking the taxpayer’s tax position and the information must be within the taxpayer’s “possession or power”.  The Tribunal’s application of the second of these tests confirms several established principles concerning the circumstances in which a subsidiary may be required to provide information held by its parent.

The case arose from an HMRC enquiry into the transfer pricing method Lifeplus used for products purchased from its US parent, Eurark. Among other documents, the Schedule 36 notice sought Eurark’s consolidated group financial statements. (In the transfer pricing context, it should be noted that an express override now permits HMRC to require certain specified transfer pricing records even where another group entity holds them and they are not within the taxpayer’s direct possession or power.)

Lifeplus successfully challenged HMRC’s request on the basis that the information was not reasonably required and, in any event, was not within Lifeplus’ possession or power.

What documents are ‘reasonably required’ under a schedule 36 notice?

Under Schedule 36, HMRC are entitled to request documents and information which are “reasonably required” for the purposes of checking the taxpayer’s tax position. Lifeplus argued that there was no rational connection between the contents of Eurark’s accounts and the tax position under enquiry , namely which transfer pricing method Lifeplus should have adopted. HMRC had not explained why the information they received was lacking or what the parent or group accounts contained that would be relevant to their enquiry.

Citing Kotton, the Tribunal emphasised the need to establish a “rational connection” between the information or documents requested and the underlying investigation.

The Tribunal held that the transfer pricing method adopted by Lifeplus did not rely upon Eurark’s company accounts and therefore HMRC had not discharged the burden of proving that the documents were reasonably required in the context of the underlying transfer pricing enquiry.

The OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines, supported Lifeplus’ position. The transfer pricing method was adopted in accordance with processes set out in the OECD guidelines. Whilst not determinative, the fact that the OECD guidelines state that once a one-sided transfer pricing method has been properly selected, there is generally no reason for the tax authority to ask for the accounts of the foreign associated enterprise assisted Lifeplus’ arguments that that Eurak’s accounts were not reasonably required.

Were the documents within Lifeplus’ ‘possession or power’?

Lifeplus submitted that it did not have access to Eurark’s financial statements without the parent company’s consent and therefore did not have “possession or power” of the financial statements. There was no legally enforceable right, de facto arrangement or general consent that Lifeplus could rely on to obtain the information.

The Tribunal’s decision discuses the long-established principle of separate legal personality, noting that the company directors could not be compelled to exercise their powers in accordance with another company’s wishes and also had a statutory duty to avoid conflicts of interest. Lifeplus, as a subsidiary, did not control its parent. A corporate relationship and some practical influence was not, without more, sufficient to establish “power”. The fact that a UK subsidiary shared senior personnel with its parent, or had previously obtained particular information from it, did not necessarily give it a continuing ability to compel the production of other documents. Nor did access granted for a specific purpose create a more general power to obtain information. Lifeplus’ previous limited access to information for settlement purposes did not establish a broader right to obtain its parent’s financial statements.

On the basis that the documents requested by HMRC were held securely by Eurark, and were not accessible, and that the US laws applicable to Eurark did not require it to make public disclosure of its accounts, the Tribunal was satisfied that the documents were not in Lifeplus’ possession or power.

Why this matters in practice

Schedule 36 notices are a tool used increasingly by HMRC in the course of enquiries. The Lifeplus decision helps clarify the limits on the circumstances in which HMRC can demand information, emphasising the need to show a rational connection between what is demanded and the underlying investigation.  In doing so it provides a useful basis for scrutinising notices drafted in broad, general terms. The critical question is not whether information might be useful or interesting to HMRC, but whether HMRC can demonstrate a rational connection between the particular information requested and the tax position being checked.  HMRC should be able to explain what the requested material is expected to establish and why the material already supplied is insufficient.

The Lifeplus decision is also important in illustrating the importance of the ‘possession or power’ condition as a substantive constraint on HMRC’s investigative powers. In a group context, the question is not whether the taxpayer is part of the same corporate group as the document-holder, but whether it has a presently enforceable legal right to obtain the documents from its parent or associated company. In the absence of such a right—or a specific and continuing arrangement giving access—the corporate relationship alone will not bring the documents within the taxpayer’s possession or power.

Taxpayers faced with a Schedule 36 notice should bear the Lifeplus decision in mind.  HMRC cannot use information notices to embark on ‘fishing expeditions’ for background information that might prove useful to its enquiry nor can it demand information on a purely speculative basis.  Although Lifeplus does not mean that every broadly framed information request can be resisted, it confirms that HMRC must be able to explain why the particular information sought is reasonably required and, where that information is held by another person, establish that it is within the taxpayer’s possession or power.  Where either requirement is not met, the taxpayer may have grounds to challenge the request.

Contact