Overview of Justice Manual revisions
On September 18, 2026, the Department of Justice (DOJ or the Department) announced revisions to the Justice Manual to strengthen False Claims Act (FCA) enforcement. The FCA is the federal government's primary civil tool for combating fraud. It authorizes private citizen whistleblowers, known as “relators,” to file lawsuits on the government's behalf in qui tam actions, entitling successful relators to a share of any recovery. These revisions come amid a significant uptick in FCA enforcement under the current Administration—a trend we have been tracking in our previous publications and podcasts.
The revisions clarify two aspects of FCA enforcement:
- the limits on using sub-regulatory guidance in DOJ litigation; and
- the circumstances in which the Department will seek dismissal of qui tam actions that do not serve US interests.
Together, the revisions reflect a recalibration of how the Department intends to deploy its FCA enforcement authority, narrowing reliance on nonbinding guidance while increasing oversight of qui tam litigation pursued on behalf of the government. As DOJ explained, the changes are intended to "help ensure the Department uses its enforcement authority fairly and effectively—holding fraudsters accountable for violations of binding legal or contractual obligations while seeking dismissal of meritless qui tam actions that waste taxpayer resources and impose unjustified burdens on businesses."1
Limits on sub-regulatory guidance in FCA enforcement
The first revision partially reinstates the Department's 2017 policy (from the first Trump Administration) that sub-regulatory guidance cannot impose legal obligations beyond those established by statute or regulation. Sub-regulatory guidance encompasses agency-issued materials—such as policy statements, FAQs, manuals and other informal guidance—that have not undergone formal notice-and-comment rulemaking.
This revision reflects the Department's commitment to “enforce the law, not make law through enforcement."2 Individuals and businesses will be held accountable only for violating binding legal obligations, not agency guidance lacking the force and effect of law. The revised policy does, however, preserve several legitimate uses for agency guidance in enforcement contexts, including:
Evidence of knowledge
The DOJ can use a party's awareness of a guidance document describing a statute or regulation as evidence of knowledge of the underlying legal requirement—a key consideration given that scienter (knowing or reckless conduct) is a core element of FCA liability.
Industry or professional standards
DOJ attorneys may use a guidance document as probative evidence of a party's compliance with industry or professional standards.
Establishing a duty
The DOJ may use guidance to establish the existence of a legal duty independent of the guidance itself.
Compliance with guidance
The DOJ may rely on a party's false certification of compliance with agency guidance to help establish falsity, materiality and scienter under the FCA, even where the guidance document itself is nonbinding.
Expanded use of dismissal authority in qui tam actions
The second revision clarifies that the Department must consider exercising its dismissal authority when it declines to intervene in a qui tam action and, where it does not seek dismissal, revisit that assessment as appropriate during litigation. This discretion “ensures [DOJ] enforcement efforts remain aligned with those interests and promotes the efficient use of government resources."3
Under the FCA, when a relator files a qui tam lawsuit, the DOJ has the right to intervene and take over the case or decline intervention, allowing the relator to proceed independently. Historically, the DOJ rarely moved to dismiss declined-intervention cases, leaving relators free to pursue suits without active government interest. Although the revised Justice Manual does not materially change the substantive considerations governing dismissal, it changes the process. Whereas the prior version stated that DOJ attorneys “should also consider” dismissal when recommending declination, the revised provision requires that attorneys “will in each case assess” whether the government’s interests would be served by seeking dismissal under 31 U.S.C. § 3730(c)(2)(A). Accordingly, every declination must now be accompanied by a dismissal analysis, with DOJ directed to revisit that assessment during the litigation as appropriate.
In conducting that assessment, the Department may consider a number of factors. For example, DOJ may seek dismissal to prevent “parasitic or opportunistic qui tam actions that duplicate a preexisting government investigation and add no useful information to the investigation.”4 Other considerations include preventing interference with agency programs, preserving the DOJ’s control over litigation brought on behalf of the US, and conserving government resources where the cost of litigation outweighs the expected benefit.5 Together, these factors signal a meaningful check on relator-driven litigation that does not advance federal enforcement priorities.
Practical takeaways for companies and executives
These revisions arrive amid a broader expansion of federal anti-fraud enforcement efforts. In recent months, the Administration created the Task Force to Eliminate Fraud, chaired by Vice President J.D. Vance, and the DOJ's National Fraud Enforcement Division, both of which are focused on combating fraud affecting federally funded programs. Additionally, the DOJ has reportedly “fast-tracked” its review of all False Claims Act matters involving government benefits programs to bring critical decisions in such cases to a head within 60 to 120 days. Against this backdrop, the Justice Manual revisions appear to be part of a broader effort to manage an expanding FCA docket, particularly in sectors such as healthcare, government contracting, defense and grant-funded programs, where compliance expectations are often shaped by extensive agency guidance.
The revisions have meaningful implications for businesses and executives operating in federally regulated industries or contracting with the federal government, including:
Narrowed enforcement exposure based on guidance documents
Companies should review pending or threatened FCA matters to assess whether the government’s theory of liability rests on a binding statute or regulation versus noncompliance with sub-regulatory guidance alone. Claims premised solely on the latter now face a stronger threshold challenge.
Guidance remains a meaningful source of FCA risk
Although these revisions limit DOJ’s ability to pursue FCA claims based solely on nonbinding guidance, companies should not view them as a retreat from guidance-informed enforcement. Agency guidance can still be used to establish knowledge, notice, industry standards or the contours of underlying legal obligations, and false certifications of compliance with guidance may independently support FCA liability by helping establish falsity, materiality and scienter. Moreover, courts and relators are not bound by DOJ’s internal policies, making guidance-based theories likely to remain a feature of FCA litigation.
Nonbinding guidance can become binding in practice
Even where guidance is nonbinding, compliance obligations incorporated into government contracts, provider agreements, grants, certifications or similar instruments may create enforceable duties and FCA exposure. In those circumstances, liability stems not from the guidance itself, but from the contractual, regulatory or certification obligation to comply with it. Companies should carefully review guidance-based requirements embedded in such instruments, as they may continue to serve as a basis for FCA allegations notwithstanding the Justice Manual revisions.
Greater DOJ scrutiny of declined qui tam actions
Because DOJ must now evaluate dismissal in every declined qui tam case and reassess that determination as appropriate during litigation, defendants may have additional opportunities to persuade the government that a meritless, duplicative or otherwise burdensome action no longer serves the government's interests and should be dismissed.
Proactive assessment of FCA exposure
Given the dynamic enforcement landscape, companies and executives receiving federal funds or operating under government contracts should engage experienced counsel to assess FCA exposure under these revised standards and develop appropriate compliance and litigation strategies.
These Justice Manual revisions reflect DOJ's effort to adapt its FCA enforcement framework to an expanding and increasingly complex fraud-enforcement landscape. Viewed together, the changes are less about narrowing FCA enforcement than refining how it is carried out: limiting reliance on nonbinding guidance while enhancing DOJ's ability to control the cases, legal theories and enforcement resources deployed on behalf of the government. As enforcement activity continues to grow across federally funded programs, companies should expect continued scrutiny while remaining alert to new opportunities to challenge guidance-based claims and seek dismissal of qui tam actions that no longer advance federal enforcement objectives.