On October 22, 2026, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) agreed to hear an appeal in a patent dispute, just months after deciding another.1 Historically, the SCC has only heard patent disputes every 5 to 10 years, making this recent uptick in SCC activity an exciting development in Canadian patent law.

Specifically, the SCC granted ProSlide Technology Inc. (ProSlide) leave to appeal the decision of the Federal Court of Appeal (FCA) in ProSlide Technology Inc. v. WhiteWater West Industries, Ltd., 2026 FCA 59. The SCC also granted WhiteWater West Industries, Ltd. (WhiteWater) leave to cross-appeal. The appeal asks whether, in the context of the modern global economy, a Canadian patent can be infringed by extensive design and development activities in Canada short of physically making the claimed invention. The cross-appeal raises two patent validity issues—overbreadth and utility—that are frequently before the Federal Courts.

Case history

ProSlide and WhiteWater are Canadian corporations and the two largest competitors in the global market for water slides. ProSlide sued WhiteWater for allegedly infringing certain Canadian patents. The trial court ruled in favour of WhiteWater, finding the asserted claims in the “552 Patent Family” not infringed and invalid. On appeal, the FCA upheld the trial court’s finding of non-infringement but concluded that the patent claims were valid, leading to applications to the SCC for leave to appeal on non-infringement (from ProSlide) and for leave to cross-appeal on invalidity (from WhiteWater).

On October 22, 2026, the SCC granted leave to appeal and cross-appeal. As is typical, the SCC did not provide reasons for granting leave. Below, we summarize the issues that will likely be before the SCC, based on the issues before the FCA and the parties’ leave applications.

Issues before the SCC

Infringement: Before the FCA, there was no dispute that WhiteWater’s products incorporate the essential elements of the asserted claims. The question was whether WhiteWater’s design and development activities in Canada amounted to patent infringement, when none of its products was physically manufactured, assembled, or used in Canada. In affirming non-infringement, the FCA agreed with the trial court that “there is no basis in law to find that generating detailed computer-aided designs and mechanical drawings in Canada is ‘making’ the claimed invention, where the invention as claimed is for a physical object” (our report here). ProSlide’s leave application asks the SCC to interpret “making… the invention” under section 42 of the Patent Act to include such design activities, particularly in light of modern digital technology and global supply chains.

Validity:

  • Overbreadth: The FCA reversed the trial court’s finding that the claims were overly broad, as that finding appeared based on the inventor’s testimony of what he contemplated while developing the patented product, without considering the patent’s disclosure (our report here). WhiteWater’s leave application (cross-appeal) asks the SCC to resolve whether there are indeed two branches to the overbreadth doctrine, namely (i) broader than the invention disclosed in the patent and (ii) broader than the invention made or contemplated by the inventor.
  • Utility: The FCA upheld the trial court’s finding that the utility of the claimed subject matter was soundly predicted, as the patent disclosed both a factual basis (e.g., computer-aided designs simulating ride paths) and a sound line of reasoning supporting utility. WhiteWater’s leave application asks the SCC to address whether, outside of pharmaceutical patents, sound prediction has a disclosure requirement and, if so, what that requirement entails.
  • ProSlide Technology Inc. v. WhiteWater West Industries, Ltd., 2026 FCA 59
  • ProSlide Technology Inc. v. Whitewater West Industries, Ltd., SCC case no. 42358, judgment granting leave to appeal and cross-appeal; materials from leave applications

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Pharmascience Inc. v. Janssen Inc., 2026 SCC 26.

Contact