Introduction
In the four articles of this venture capital series, we discuss some of the most commonly used equity and equity-like instruments used by emerging companies in the UK, the US and Canada. Last week we discussed convertible debt and warrants.1
In previous weeks we discussed:
- Priced equity rounds
- SAFEs and ASAs,
- Convertible debt and warrants
Up this week: Token issuances and warrants
This article is the last in our venture capital article series (all links to which can be found here2).
Token issuances
Web3 early-stage companies may seek to raise financing through funding structures involving the issuance of ‘crypto-tokens’ (Tokens), or the acquisition of preferential contractual rights (such as warrants) in connection with the future purchase of Tokens.
Tokens may:
- have a certain functional use within the companies’ blockchain platform (such as granting the holder access to certain services, giving the holder discounts or attaching certain governance rights);
- act as a security, giving the holder rights to a share in profit and/or fixed payments;
- represent rights to a share in non-fungible objects, including NFTs and traditional “real world” assets.
Tokens differ from ‘cryptocurrencies’, which are digital currencies based on a particular blockchain with the sole function of storing value and serving as a medium for exchange.
Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs)
- Rather than offering equity or debt, early-stage companies may decide to issue Tokens in exchange for financial investment.
- Compared to equity fundraising, ICOs can be advantageous for early-stage Web3 companies, since investors will invest directly in the development of the relevant platform in exchange for Tokens which will have functionality over such platform and (presuming success of the platform) are usually deemed to have some value.
- ICOs also allow for the market sentiment towards early-stage companies and their products to be accurately assessed and an ICO will typically be launched off the back of a whitepaper setting out the intentions and functionality of the proposed platform and Tokens.
- However, the lack of regulatory clarity surrounding ICOs may present a risk to investors and investees alike. For example, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK note that a determination as to whether a given ICO constitutes a regulated activity must be decided on a case-by-case basis and financial promotion restrictions may apply to companies seeking to raise funds via an ICO. In Canada, provincial securities regulators have indicated that ICOs should contact their provincial securities regulator to start the registration process.3
- If an ICO is unregulated, investors are not afforded regulatory protections, and will not benefit from regulatory recourse.
Simple Agreements for Future Tokens (SAFTs)
- These are modelled on Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFEs) and require upfront payment in consideration for the issue of Tokens at a later date (often upon a future ICO, once the platform has been created and genesis Tokens generated). The number of Tokens will often be valued based on a future ICO.
- The advantage of these is that they allow for early stage funding to development platform and Token infrastructure before the ICO can take place.
- The same regulatory considerations will apply to SAFTs as to ICOs.
- Companies may also choose to fund raise via Simple Agreements for Future Tokens and Equity (SAFTEs), where investors may be entitled to either Tokens or equity in the issuing company, depending on the occurrence, and sequence of specified conversion events.
Token Warrants
- These are instruments pursuant to which the warrant holder acquires the right, but typically not the obligation, to purchase Tokens in the issuing company following a trigger event and prior to a specified expiration date, at a specified price or linked to a valuation of a subsequent ICO or other event.
- These have gained increasing market prevalence in light of the uncertainty surrounding the scope of regulation in relation to SAFTs.
- Token warrants may be used in combination with SAFEs or CLNs to ensure investors receive governance rights and less volatility in returns, or as a way to formalise the issuance of Tokens on certain contractual milestones (for example to a developer involved in the development of the platform).
Venture Capital Funding Structure Overview
| Funding structure | Time consuming / long form documents | Valuation of company or price per share (or Token) decided at a later date? | Repayable? | Maturity date? |
| Priced equity round | Yes | No | No | No |
| ASA | No | Yes | No | No |
| SAFE | No | Yes | No | No |
| CD | No | Yes | Yes (plus interest) | Yes |
| Equity Warrant | No | No | No | Yes |
| ICO | No | No | No | No |
| SAFT / SAFTES | No | Yes | No | No |
| Token Warrants | No | Yes | No | Yes |
Footnotes
-
Venture Capital Series: Early stage funding structures Article 3 - Convertible Debt and Warrants | …
-
Venture Capital Series: Early stage funding structures Article 1 - Priced equity | Global law firm …
Venture Capital Series: Early stage funding structures Article 2 –SAFEs and ASAs | Global law firm …
Venture Capital Series: Early stage funding structures Article 3 - Convertible Debt and Warrants | … -
See, for example, the guidance provided by the Ontario Securities Commission here: https://www.osc.ca/en/industry/registration-and-compliance/registered-crypto-asset-trading-platforms#:~:text=On%20March%2029%2C%202021%2C%20the,platform%20decisions%20in%20other%20jurisdictions.