The EU's approach to prediction markets and event contracts1
Prediction markets have attracted significant global attention in recent years, with some analysts estimating that trading volumes could reach USD 1 trillion by 2030. While platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket have driven rapid growth in the United States, the European Union has taken a markedly different regulatory path — one rooted in its existing financial instruments framework under the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (“MiFID II”) and shaped by longstanding investor protection concerns.
Prediction markets through the lens of MiFID II
Unlike the United States, where the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) is actively developing a bespoke regulatory framework for event contracts and prediction markets, the EU does not have standalone legislation governing these products nor has it issued a dedicated, standalone publication specifically addressing prediction markets or event contracts as a regulatory category. In addition, as far as we are aware, no EU Member State regulator has so far issued such a publication.
As such whether or not event contracts and prediction markets fall within the EU’s financial services regulatory perimeter is open to debate. In order to fall within this perimeter a key question is whether such contracts fall within the definition of "financial instruments" under MiFID II. The list of “financial instruments” regulated under MiFID II is set out in Section C of Annex I to the Directive.
Arguably the most relevant financial instruments for the purposes of event contracts and prediction markets are: derivatives relating to financial underlyings (Section Point (4) of Section C), financial contracts for differences (Point (9) of Section C) and the “catch all provision” covering derivatives relating to "climatic variables, freight rates, or inflation rates or other official economic statistics" that must be settled in cash, as well as "any other derivative contracts relating to assets, rights, obligations, indices and measures not otherwise mentioned in this Section, which have the characteristics of other derivative financial instruments" (Point (10) of Section C).
Furthermore, the European Commission has previously published a Q&A2 confirming that the binary options described within it fall within the scope of MiFID II financial instruments. The Commission stated that: “As the binary option you are referring has the features of a derivative contract settled in cash (cf Articles 37 and 38 of the Implementing Regulation No 1287/2006), such binary products appear to meet the definition of ‘financial instruments’ laid down in Section C of Annex I to MiFID. Therefore, companies offering investment services and activities in these binary options should be authorised as investment firms under MiFID.”
Also, the European Securities and Markets Authority (“ESMA”) has subsequently defined a binary option as a cash-settled derivative in which "payment at close-out or expiry of a predetermined fixed monetary amount or zero depends on whether one or more specified events in relation to the underlying occur at, or prior to, the derivative's expiry"3.
Similar but not the same?
The European Commission's Q&As on MiFID II describes a contract for difference as “a contract for differences in relation to MiFID instruments, currencies, interest rates or other financial indices." It adds that "A sports, political or similar CFD, which depended on the results of a match, election or other variable not mentioned in Section C(10), and which does not otherwise fall under Section C(9) or C(5), would not be covered." So, an event contract with a non-financial underlying would be out of scope of the definition of a contract for difference. Where the underlying is a financial underlying — i.e., MiFID instruments, currencies, interest rates, or financial indices the position may be less clear although a key distinguishing feature of contracts for differences is that they do not provide for a binary payout unlike an event contract. Contract for differences provides the holder with exposure to fluctuations in the price, level, or value of an underlying, such that the profit or loss is proportional to the magnitude of the price movement.
It appears that event contracts and binary options share some important similarities: both are contracts that provide for a fixed monetary pay-out contingent on whether a specified condition is satisfied at or prior to the contract's expiry, with the investor receiving either the predetermined amount or nothing at all. This all-or-nothing approach means that, where the specified condition relates to the price, level, or value of a financial underlying — such as a security, currency pair, interest rate, commodity, or financial index — an event contract may be economically indistinguishable from a binary option.
The critical variable in determining whether a given event contract falls to be classified as a binary option under MiFID II is the nature of its underlying: an event contract referencing a financial variable enumerated in Section C of Annex I to MiFID II (for example, whether an equity index will close above a specified level on a given date) is likely to satisfy the definition of a derivative contract of a binary or fixed-outcomes nature, whereas an event contract referencing a non-financial event (such as a sporting result or a political outcome not linked to any economic measure) would most likely fall outside the MiFID II perimeter altogether.
Even in instances of financially-referenced event contracts the classification may not be automatic: the contract must exhibit the characteristics of a derivative financial instrument — including, in particular, that its value is derived from and fluctuates with an underlying asset or variable — and there are substantive arguments that a prediction market contract offering a fixed payoff on a discrete binary event, rather than a return that moves proportionally with the value of an underlying, may not satisfy that threshold condition.
As always with financial services, the devil is in the detail - the question of classification remains fact-sensitive and product-specific.
Consequences of being a MiFID II financial instrument
Should an event contract be classified as a MiFID II financial instrument there are certain consequences. The platform offering such contracts would be subject to the full suite of MiFID II’s obligations4: authorisation requirements, conduct of business rules, appropriateness and suitability assessments, product governance requirements, and best execution obligations.
It is also noteworthy that ESMA has confirmed that binary options do not meet the criteria to be regarded as "non-complex" financial instruments under the combined reading of Article 25(4) of MiFID II and Article 57 of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565. This means that even if prediction market contracts were not subject to an outright prohibition, it could not be distributed on an execution-only basis without an appropriateness assessment — the platform would be required to evaluate whether the product was appropriate for the client's knowledge and experience before proceeding with a transaction.
And there is also ESMA's product intervention decision, first adopted in May 2018 under Article 40 of MiFIR, which prohibits the marketing, distribution, or sale of binary options to retail clients across the Union5. This prohibition has been renewed repeatedly and has since been adopted on a permanent basis by most EU national competent authorities6.
Crypto assets
Under the Regulation in markets in crypto assets (MiCA) a “crypto asset” is broadly defined as "a digital representation of a value or a right which may be transferred and stored electronically, using distributed ledger technology or similar technology". On the basis of this definition, MiCA covers three categories of crypto asset: electronic money tokens (EMTs), asset-referenced tokens (ARTs) and crypto assets other than EMTs and ARTs. MiCA does not, however, apply to crypto assets that are unique and non-fungible, to tokens that are non-transferable, or to crypto assets that already fall within the scope of existing financial services legislation like MiFID II.
Whether an event contract would fall within MiCA’s scope depends on the specific characteristics of the contract and the technology used to issue or settle it. There are a number of things to consider. For example, whether the event contract constitutes a “digital representation of a value or of a right”. If the contract was structured as a bilateral wager or personal contractual claim that did not represent a standalone transferable value or right in digital form, it may not satisfy this limb of the definition. Even if it did, the contract would also need to be capable of being “transferred and stored electronically, using distributed ledger technology or similar technology”. If the contract were settled off-chain — for example, through a traditional centralised platform, a conventional database, or bilateral clearing arrangements — without any use of DLT or a comparable decentralised record-keeping technology, it may fall outside the MiCA definition on that basis as well. Should the event contract overcome these hurdles and meet MiCA’s definition of a crypto asset the platform facilitating trading in such contracts would likely need to be authorised as a crypto-asset service provider and comply with MiCA's market abuse, disclosure, and prudential requirements.
Gambling
Where an event contract does not satisfy the criteria for classification as a financial instrument under MiFID II or MiCA it may nonetheless fall within the scope of national gambling legislation in the relevant Member State. There is no sector-specific EU legislation in the field of gambling services, and each Member State retains broad discretion to define, regulate, restrict, or prohibit gambling activities within its territory, provided it complies with the fundamental freedoms established under the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. Several Member State gambling authorities — including the Autorité Nationale des Jeux in France and the Kansspelautoriteit in the Netherlands — have already taken enforcement action against prediction market platforms on the basis that they constitute illegal gambling services. A detailed review of Member State gambling legislation and the circumstances in which event contracts may be characterised as gambling products under national law is outside the scope of this note.
Contrast with the US
The EU's approach stands in sharp contrast to developments in the United States, where the CFTC has signalled a willingness to accommodate prediction markets within a regulated framework. In March 2026, the CFTC issued a staff advisory and published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking aimed at developing comprehensive rules for these markets.
The EU, by contrast, has maintained its protective stance. While the MiFID II review process continues — with an implementation update published in April 2026 — there is no indication that the European Commission or ESMA intend to carve out an exemption or create a tailored regime for prediction markets. The existing framework of MiFID II classification and ESMA's binary options prohibition remains the governing regulatory reality for any entity seeking to offer prediction market products to EU-based investors.
Implications for market participants
For market participants and platforms considering EU expansion, the message is clear: prediction market event contracts are likely to be classified as financial instruments, their offering to retail clients is prohibited under ESMA's product intervention measures, and any activity in this space requires full compliance with MiFID II's authorisation and conduct requirements.
Footnotes
-
See also our other global briefing notes and podcasts on prediction markets and event contracts: Split the Difference: Episode 19 – Prediction Markets and Event Contracts | Global law firm | Norton Rose Fulbright; Prediction markets in the spotlight: Key legal issues in the UAE | Global law firm | Norton Rose Fulbright; Prediction markets at a crossroads: Preemption, enforcement and rulemaking | United States | Global law firm | Norton Rose Fulbright
-
See European Commission’s questions and answers on MiFID \
-
ESMA - Additional information on the agreed product intervention measures relating to contracts for differences and binary options (March 27, 2018)\
-
Also obligations under the Markets in Financial Instruments Regulation\
-
ESMA Notice - Notice of ESMA’s Product Intervention Decisions in relation to contracts for differences and binary options\
-
ESMA Decision (EU) 2018/795 of May 22, 2018 to temporarily prohibit the marketing, distribution or sale of binary options to retail clients in the Union in accordance with Article 40 of Regulation (EU) No 600/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council\