This briefing covers a round-up of a few cases that have caught our attention during the first six months of 2026, together with our thoughts on some of the key issues and developments we expect to shape the remainder of the year.
Incorporation of standard terms
Finco International AG v Integra Petrochemicals Europe AG [2026] EWHC 727 (Comm)
The Commercial Court dismissed a buyer’s claim for restitution following its purported termination of a contract for the sale of petrochemical cargo on BP Oil International Limited General Terms and Conditions for the Sale and Purchases of Crude Oil and Petroleum Products (the “BP GTCs”). The buyer argued that the seller’s failure to deliver within the “Delivery Dates”, specified in the contract recap, was a repudiatory breach. However, the Court, held that when the parties amended the delivery term from delivery at the discharge terminal to delivery on loading, Part 3 of the BP GTCs ceased to apply. Instead, the entire CIF scheme under Part 2 of the BP GTCs applied, including section 11.3, which rendered the stated delivery dates merely “indicative” of the expected discharge window rather than an obligation to complete delivery within those dates. The seller’s obligation was limited to ensuring the vessel tendered NOR at the loading terminal at a time consistent with arrival within the indicative dates, which it had done. The Court rejected the buyer’s attempt to create a “hybrid” contract retaining the binding DES delivery dates while otherwise switching to CIF terms, finding “there is nothing in the contract terms to indicate they did not intend the full consequences of that change, as flow from the BP GTCs, to apply”.
On the separate nomination issue, the court held that sections 14.6.1 and 14.6.2 of the BP GTCs operate together to create a single mechanism for vessel rejection. Section 14.6.2 defines the right of rejection on reasonable grounds, and s.14.6.1 prescribes that it may be exercised by giving notice within 1 Business Day of receiving the nomination. Failure to reject within that window means the vessel is deemed accepted. The buyer’s various communications, by instant message and email, were invalid for multiple reasons: instant messages could not constitute contractual notice under s.70(4) of the BP GTCs; the early emails were not sufficiently unequivocal to amount to a rejection; and any communications after the first Business Day were too late.
Notably, the judge found that the buyer’s ground for rejection (the vessel being too large for the chosen terminal) was objectively reasonable prior to the seller taking responsibility for offloading the cargo via barges, but the rejections still failed because of the procedural deficiencies.
Key takeaways
Parties trading on incorporated general terms (such as the BP GTCs) should be aware that amending a single term may engage a scheme of provisions. Contractual notices (including vessel rejections) must be given by the prescribed means and within strict time limits; instant messaging will not suffice where the terms prohibit it, and a failure to act within the contractual window may be treated as deemed acceptance.
Mercuria Energy Trading SA v Onex DMCC [2026] EWHC 130 (Comm)
Here, the Commercial Court also considered how the special provisions of a contract fit with the underlying BP GTCs.
The Court dismissed the buyer’s claim that a cargo of Iraqi oil products, which did not meet some of the features described as “typicals” in the product description, was therefore in breach of the sale contract. The contract described the products as high sulphur straight-run fuel “in line with the following typicals…and meeting the following guarantees…” The table of typicals set out, among other things, the maximum organic chloride content (“OC”). The table of guaranteed specifications did not reference the OC. The OC of the cargo exceeded that set out in the “typicals” table.
The Court construed the contract as a whole and found that sections 57.1.61 and 59.1.1 of the BP GTCs set out the definition of typicals as indications of quality or characteristics, which would not amount to product description. The inclusion of the wording “in line with” did not elevate the typicals to warranties as to the product and therefore the product only had to meet the guaranteed specifications. The Judge found “no relevant inconsistency between the special conditions and the printed terms” such that the inconsistency clause, which gave precedence to the special provisions, was not engaged. The Judge explained that, had the buyers wished the seller to be under a contractual obligation as to OC levels, they should have included a guarantee in the contract.
The buyer’s alternative arguments, that the seller was in breach of guarantee as to the cargo being 100% SOMO IRAQI HSSR, and that the level of OC was such that the cargo no longer complied with specification, were both rejected.
If you would like to read more about this decision, please refer to our briefing here.
Waiver
Trans Trade RK SA v Sebat Shipping and Trading Company [2026] EWHC 950 (Comm)
The High Court allowed an appeal under section 69 of the Arbitration Act 1996, setting aside an arbitral award of approximately US$840,000 and confirming that waiver of a contractual right requires actual knowledge of that right and unequivocal conduct amounting to an election not to rely on it.
The dispute arose out of a shipping contract for the carriage of barley to Germany. The shipowner served a formal notice confirming the vessel was ready to be unloaded (a "Notice of Readiness" or NOR) when the vessel arrived within the contractual port area but before it had arrived at the contractual destination and anchored, rendering the notice invalid. No further notice was served. When the vessel later berthed and the cargo hatches were opened the following morning, dangerous levels of toxic gas were discovered. The vessel was ordered away as a result, and did not berth again for over two months. Despite the invalidity of the NOR, the arbitral tribunal awarded demurrage (a daily penalty for delay in unloading) on the basis that, absent a valid NOR, laytime commenced once cargo operations began.
On appeal, the High Court held that the tribunal's approach was wrong in law. Drawing on the Court of Appeal's decisions in The Mexico I and The Happy Day, the judge confirmed that an invalid notice is incapable of starting the clock unless there is a separate agreement, waiver or estoppel. Critically, the judge rejected the shipowner's argument that there existed a principle of "deemed waiver" — a less rigorous form of waiver said to arise automatically from the commencement of performance. The judge confirmed that the requirements for waiver by election are stringent: (i) the party alleged to have waived its rights must have had actual knowledge of both the facts giving rise to the right and the existence of the right itself; and (ii) it must have acted unequivocally in a manner inconsistent with exercising that right. Here, there was no finding that the charterer knew the notice was invalid, and the tribunal had not considered waiver at all.
This decision is a clear reminder that there is no shortcut to establishing waiver. A party will not be treated as having waived a contractual right merely by continuing to perform. The rejection of "deemed waiver" affirms that the orthodox requirements — actual knowledge of the right in question and unequivocal election not to rely on it — must be met in full.
Insurance
Oceanus Capital SARL v Lloyd’s Insurance Company**[2025] EWHC 3293 (Comm), [2026] EWCA Civ 863 (“M/V ‘VYSSOS’”)**
The Commercial Court held that a mortgagee lender was entitled to claim under a Mortgagee's Interest Insurance ("MII") policy after the owner's war risks insurance failed to respond, in circumstances involving forged additional insurance cover. Having taken both an assignment of the owner's insurance policies and a separate MII policy, Oceanus's lending was secured against the Vyssos, which struck a mine and became a constructive total loss shortly after the owner obtained what proved to be a forged additional war risks cover note for a voyage into Ukrainian waters. The war risks insurers declined cover for breach of warranties, and Lloyd's declined the MII claim on various grounds including that the forged cover was not a risk it had assumed. The Court found for Oceanus, holding that the proximate cause of its loss was the mine strike, not the forged cover. Specifically, the court clarified that the MII policy responded wherever a covered loss occurred and the owner's insurance failed to respond, especially in circumstances where the failure to respond arose due to the owner's own misconduct. Oceanus's apparent consent to the voyage was also vitiated by the fraud, leaving its loss fortuitous rather than self-induced.
This is the first judicial consideration of the standard London MII wording. Lloyd’s were subsequently granted permission to appeal the Commercial Court's first instance judgment. However, the appeal was dismissed, with the Court of Appeal finding again that Oceanus was entitled to recover under its MII policy, confirming the Commercial Court’s decision on largely the same reasoning. Specifically, the Court of Appeal held that the insured loss was Oceanus' security interest in the Vessel, and that the relevant insured perils operated together and proximately, to cause the loss regardless of the non-existent forged cover. On privity, the Court held that Oceanus' consent to the voyage was vitiated by the forged cover note and therefore Oceanus could not be privy to the breach. For the same reason, the fortuity argument also failed but, in any event, the loss was caused by the fortuitous mine strike itself.
If you would like to read about this case in more detail, please see our briefing note on the Commercial Court decision here and the Court of Appeal decision here.
Sanctions
Tonzip Maritime (Singapore) PTE Ltd (formerly Tonzip Maritime Ltd) v 2 Rivers PTE Ltd (formerly Coral Energy PTE Ltd) [2026] EWCA Civ 641
The Court of Appeal allowed an appeal by Owners finding that they were entitled to refuse Charterers’ orders because compliance with those orders would, in Owners’ reasonable judgment, “expose” them to a real risk of sanctions liability. The Court of Appeal agreed with the High Court that a reasonable apprehension of sanctions risk was sufficient to refuse the orders, and that Owners did not have to conclude that sanctions would actually be breached. However, they disagreed with the High Court’s finding that the Owners could not have reasonably concluded a real exposure to sanctions risk on the facts available if there was no positive conclusion with regards to the Charterer’s association with sanctioned individuals.
The Court considered the language of the EPS Sanctions Clause in the voyage charterparty (ExxonMobil VOY2005) in its own contractual context, preferring to interpret the words “expose” and “such risk” in relation to the contract before them rather than drawing on other market clauses and definitions. They also considered the terms in light of the wider commercial context, highlighting the lack of a clear answer and the difficulties owners face in making decisions, in particular because:
- The clause required Owners to make a prospective determination of the effect of future (or continued) compliance with an order;
- The factual issues arising in a sanctions context will frequently be hidden from public view and will be contestable;
- Sanctions laws are generally broadly phrased and complex; and
- Owners will often have to make their decision very quickly.
Taking into account these commercial constraints, the court found that the decision of the Owners to refuse the Charterers’ orders, based on the limited factual evidence available to them – including the alleged connection between the Charterer and a sanctioned individual – was one which a reasonable shipowner may reach and was therefore not in breach of the charterparty.
If you would like to read about this case in more detail, please see our briefing note here.
Emerging trends: Looking ahead into the next six months
The cases above highlight several themes likely to remain relevant to shipping practitioners in the second half of 2026.
- **Strict compliance with contractual notices and procedural formalities: **Finco International and Trans Trade demonstrate that English courts insist on strict compliance with contractual notice regimes, irrespective of the underlying merits of a party’s position. Where a contract prescribes a specific mechanism, method or timeframe for exercising a right, parties should adhere to it.
- Holistic construction of standard-form terms over piecemeal interpretation: Finco International and Mercuria, both concerning the BP GTCs, illustrate courts construing standard industry terms as an integrated scheme rather than severable provisions. Both decisions confirm established principles of contractual construction, namely that the printed terms of standard forms should be read as a coherent whole and that clear, deliberate drafting choices will be respected over an expansive reading of ancillary wording. Traders should take particular care when varying incorporated general terms, as this may have unintended knock-on effects on the wider contractual scheme.
- Reaffirmation of the test for waiver: Trans Trade reaffirms orthodoxy, where the High Court rejected the notion of “deemed waiver” arising automatically from continued performance, confirming that waiver by election requires both actual knowledge of the right in question and unequivocal conduct inconsistent with its exercise. This expressly rejects arguments that a more relaxed or commercially intuitive standard of waiver should apply where a party continues under a contract.
- **Geopolitical instability continuing to generate insurance and sanctions disputes: **Oceanus and Tonzip both stem from heightened geopolitical risk in and around conflict zones. Both decisions demonstrate the courts’ willingness to accommodate the practical difficulties owners and financiers face when operating with incomplete information and fast-moving sanctions regimes. This category of disputes is expected to grow as sanctions regimes expand and geopolitical tensions persist.
With thanks to Mary Fraser, Anna de Freitas, Humza Nadeem and Chris Menon for their assistance in preparing this post.