Jonathan Lafrance

Partner
Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP
jonathan.lafrance@nortonrosefulbright.com
Jonathan
Lafrance
Jonathan Lafrance
Montréal
1 Place Ville Marie, Suite 2700
Montréal
Quebec
H3B 1R1
Canada
+1 514 847 4323
Calgary
888 3 St SW, Suite 3400
Calgary
Alberta
T2P 5C5
Canada
+1 403 267 8222

Jonathan Lafrance is a Chambers and Partners’ ranked tax litigator and one of Canada’s leading lawyers concerning returns of donations by foundations and charitable organizations. Based in Montreal, he has developed a national practice helping clients resolve tax disputes.

Mr. Lafrance has represented clients in more than 100 court cases leading to either a decision on the merits or favourable out-of-court settlements. According to Chambers and Partners, clients say that Jonathan “offers excellent client service and is focused on providing comprehensive solutions.” Clients have also mentioned “We find working with Jonathan gratifying and we are fully confident in his capabilities.”

In recent years, Jonathan has served as lead counsel in the most high-profile cases involving returns of donations by foundations and charities, guiding his clients through the complex legal and tax implications of returning charitable donations to unfit donors, including obtaining court orders and navigating related tax audits.

Over the years, he has argued cases before the Tax Court of Canada, the Federal Court and the Federal Court of Appeal; the Court of Quebec; the Superior Court of Quebec and the Quebec Court of Appeal; the Supreme Court of British Columbia; the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench; the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in the context of tax disputes against the federal and provincial tax authorities. He also represented clients in Supreme Court of Canada cases, including one on the merits and four at the leave to appeal stage.

Mr. Lafrance has represented clients in a variety of matters, including domestic and international income tax, GST/HST, collection measures, protection of tax information, judicial review, fuel tax, tobacco tax, property tax, rectification and rescission. He regularly assists individuals, public and private corporations as well as registered charities in the context of tax audits, financial governance and regulatory obligations.

Mr. Lafrance teaches tax litigation at the University of Sherbrooke. Mr. Lafrance was a judicial clerk with the judges of the Tax Court of Canada in 2012-2013.

He has authored several articles and is an active speaker in the tax community.

Representative experience

Mr. Lafrance has recently represented the following clients:

  • CAE Inc., Tax Court of Canada –Confidentiality order in the context of a tax dispute on the sale of flight simulators.
  • The CSL Group Inc., Court of Quebec – Solicitor-client privilege raised by Revenue Quebec in the context of discoveries.
  • Pierre Elliott Trudeau Foundation, File No. 500-17-125795-230 (2024). Quebec Superior Court – Rescission of donation. Rescission of charitable donations in the context of alleged foreign interference.
  • Lark Investments Ltd., 2024 TCC 30. Tax Court of Canada – General anti-avoidance rule. Successful striking of the Crown’s argument in applying GAAR to certain transactions.
  • Foix, 2023 CAF 38. Federal Court of Appeal and Tax Court of Canada – Hybrid transaction. Most recent case involving applying the anti-avoidance rule set in s. 84(2) of the Income Tax Act to a hybrid sale of shares and assets.
  • Foundation of the University of Quebec in Abitibi-Temiscamingue, 2022 QCCS 3068. Quebec Superior Court – Rescission of donation. Rescission of charitable donations in the context of alleged misconduct by the donor
  • Gestion F. Bélisle Ltd., 2021 QCCA 1352. Quebec Court of Appeal – Judicial rectification. Rectification obtained in the context of estate planning of a private oil distribution business.
  • Groupe Custeau, 2020 QCCA 1496 (CanLII). Quebec Court of Appeal (leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada by Revenue Quebec denied) – General anti-avoidance rule (GAAR). Non-application of GAAR to transactions relating to the paid-up capital of a private corporation.
  • CPA Canada, 2017 FCA 61, in the context of its intervention in BP Canada Energy Company v. Canada (National Revenue). Federal Court of Appeal – Audit powers. Successful intervention by CPA Canada to restrain the tax authorities' access to tax accrual working papers. Cited as one of the top 10 decisions of 2017 by LEXPERT.
  • Laurentian Bank, 2020 CCI 73. Tax Court of Canada – Income Tax. Deductibility of fees incurred by a bank in the context of the issuance of shares through a private placement by way of subscription receipts.

Awards and recognitions

  • Best Lawyers in Canada: Tax Law, 2023-2027
  • Chambers Canada, Nationwide: Tax litigation, Chambers and Partners, 2025-2027
  • Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory, 2025-2026: recommended in Litigation - Corporate Tax
  • Chambers Worldwide: Tax litigation, 2025
  • Stikeman Elliott Award, International Taxation, 2012

Education

M.Fisc., University of Sherbrooke, 2014
J.D., Common law and transnational law, University of Sherbrooke, 2011
LL.B., University of Sherbrooke, 2010

Admissions

  • Quebec 2013
  • Alberta 2022

Speaking engagements

  • Navigating the Complex World of Unfit Donors and Donation Returns – CAGP’s 32nd National Conference on Strategic Philanthropy (April 2026)
  • Recent Cases on Tax Disputes and Tax Administration – Association de planification fiscale et financière (March 2026)
  • Out-of-court Settlements with Tax Authorities: Best Practices – Canadian Tax Foundation (January 2026)
  • The Rebirth of Tax Rectification in Canada – Association de planification fiscale et financière (March 2025)
  • Returning Gifts and "Unfit Donors" – Association de planification fiscal et financière (February 2025)
  • Objection! Or How to Ensure Legal Evidence – Canadian Tax Foundation Seminar (October 2024)
  • The Current Landscape of Tax Controversy – Recent Cases and Developments – Celebrating the Tax Court of Canada, Canadian Tax Foundation (October 2023)
  • Update: Tax Working Papers, Mandatory Disclosure and the Evolving Powers of  Tax Authorities – Tax Executive Institute (October 2022)
  • Guidance to Tax Professionals Regarding Their Duty of Care to Clients – British Columbia Tax Conference (September 2022)
  • Tax Treatment of Transaction Fees – Canadian Tax Foundation Seminar (2020)

Languages

  • English
  • French

Publications

  • Transfer Pricing Law Review – Third Edition, Law Business Research (2019)
  • Transfer Pricing Law Review – Second Edition, Law Business Research (2018)
  • Transfer Pricing Law Review – First Edition, Law Business Research (2017)
  • L'interrogatoire au préalable selon le nouveau Code civil, Stratège (APFF), June 2016, Volume 21, no. 2 (2016)
  • L'évolution de la preuve et les opérations d'évitement, Stratège (APFF), April 2014, Vol 19, no. 2. (2014)
  • Canada and the United States reach an intergovernmental agreement on Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act – April 15, 2014, NRFC external publication (2014)

Membership and activities

  • Canadian Bar Association
  • Association de planification fiscale et financière (tax and financial planning association)
  • Canadian Tax Foundation
  • Lecturer - tax litigation, University of Sherbrooke law faculty
Bio